Cleveland-Cliffs (CLF) Q4 2024 Earnings Call Transcript

On uncommon events, our knowledgeable group of analysts points a “Double Down” inventory suggestion for corporations that they assume are about to pop. If you happen to’re fearful you’ve already missed your likelihood to speculate, now’s the very best time to purchase earlier than it’s too late. And the numbers communicate for themselves:

• Nvidia: in case you invested $1,000 once we doubled down in 2009, you’d have $337,818!*

• Apple: in case you invested $1,000 once we doubled down in 2008, you’d have $46,848!*

• Netflix: in case you invested $1,000 once we doubled down in 2004, you’d have $533,073!*

Proper now, we’re issuing “Double Down” alerts for 3 unbelievable corporations, and there is probably not one other likelihood like this anytime quickly.

Proceed »

*Inventory Advisor returns as of February 24, 2025

This led to the idle of our C6 blast furnace at Cleveland Works final quarter. A number of this weak demand setting was a operate of unnatural market components at play. Amongst these components, rates of interest stored at very excessive ranges by the Federal Reserve, negatively impacted our service middle clients’ potential to purchase metal from us. And, in fact, commerce distortions enabled by overseas international locations supporting metal overproduction continued to be a significant drawback.

Relating to commerce, the metal business has been coping with unfair competitors from overseas producers for many years. We now have all the time been very vocal in calling out every one of many issues, significantly the dumping of artificially low cost metal into the U.S. market, subsidies that overseas governments hand out with abandon to their metal producers, foreign money manipulation, weak environmental laws or lack of enforcement, and inadequate or non-existing punishment for unhealthy actors who manipulate the worldwide market. With the Trump administration in workplace, motion is being taken and we’re beginning to see optimistic indicators forward of us.

We at Cleveland-Cliffs recognize the not too long ago introduced 25% tariffs on metal imports from all international locations. These tariffs are crucial to addressing the issue and we thank the Trump administration to have the braveness to implement these tariffs. Whereas america continues to be in a internet quick place on metal, the largest exporters of metal into the U.S. are all responsible of overcapacity and overproduction.

To make issues worse, these overseas overproducers of metal are all extra carbon intensive than every one of many U.S. metal makers, that means that they overproduce metal and CO2 after which put the metal on a vessel that emits much more CO2. Cleveland-Cliffs just isn’t relying on imported inputs and we don’t depend on overseas provide chains that may be disrupted in a single day. The tariffs will penalize the overseas opponents who’ve been taking part in by a unique algorithm whereas strengthening the home producers who really spend money on American staff, American manufacturing and American provide chains.

The commerce angle is not simply vital for metal however for completed items as nicely. For the primary time in historical past, 2024 was the 12 months when gross sales of imported vehicles in america surpassed gross sales of domestically made autos. Let me repeat this level yet one more time. In 2024, the variety of imported vehicles bought to customers was larger than the variety of home produced vehicles bought in america.

That’s precisely why tariffs and a robust industrial coverage are essential to guard and power the American manufacturing base as a substitute of letting it proceed to erode. We additionally recognize that the latest tariff announcement consists of downstream merchandise containing metal, and that ought to profit our purchasers in automotive and in different sectors. The tariffs will even profit our newly acquired Stelco. That is proper.

Regardless of what some may assume, the very best monetary 12 months for Stelco within the earlier decade was 2018, when 25% tariffs on Canadian metal imports have been in place. Stelco sells greater than half of its output in Canada and we compete with different Canadian suppliers who ship the fabric into america. The Canadian metal market pricing displays the U.S. market pricing.

So any ensuing rise in pricing will circulation on to Stelco as nicely on high of the profit we’re seeing from the weakening Canadian greenback. It has now been practically 4 months of our possession of Stelco. I’ll remind everybody that our acquisition course of and evaluate by the DOJ went via seamlessly. The operational transition has been clean.

Lake Erie Works stays best-in-class from a price construction standpoint. A big portion of our anticipated synergies have already been set in movement. And we’re figuring out extra methods to maximise worth from the mix. The perfect instance is directing order flows to maximise all of our mills strengths.

This implies we will load Lake Erie with the grids they make greatest and transition among the extra subtle grades and orders to our U.S. mills. The worth we’ve got discovered right here will doubtless characterize a lot of the remaining synergies. We count on to have the $120 million in synergies set in movement earlier than the top of this 12 months.

As for the present state of play at Cliffs typically, we proceed to handle prices, optimize operations, and keep our monetary flexibility. We now have been via cycles earlier than. We all know precisely what to do. We proceed to get pleasure from full help from our buyers and we proved that after once more with the not too long ago issued senior unsecured notes, a deal that was oversubscribed and was priced in just a few hours after launching.

And as we’ve got already defined, the market is definitely pointing in our favor. Step one is the tightening of the scrap market. We now have been saying for years that the continued push towards EAFs would pressure the scrap value larger. That is precisely what’s taking place now.

Prime scrap provide is inelastic and demand retains rising. In simply two months, we’ve got seen prime costs transfer up $70 per gross ton. In the meantime, Cleveland-Cliffs is sitting precisely the place we have to be. Our ROI-based operations give us price stability, high quality consistency and provide safety.

This can be a long-term benefit that we’ll solely get stronger over time. Our order e-book is in a a lot stronger place to start out 2025 with a major uptick in demand. The enhancements in automotive have been particularly encouraging with elevated volumes from each current and new applications. We’re seeing our greatest pull charges since early final 12 months, a transparent signal that we’re recovering market share from the opponents that gave away value.

These opponents cannot win on high quality or service, in order that they gave away the farm on pricing and at the moment are struggling to ship on efficiency. Regardless of how a lot competitors tries to low-ball pricing on this market, high quality and supply efficiency all the time win in the long run. This optimistic pattern, mixed with higher demand in different core segments, places us in an incredible place for the 12 months forward. After spending the complete second half of 2024 with sub $700 HRC pricing, we’re lastly beginning to see the lengthy overdue bounce.

And we at the moment are even higher outfitted to trip this upside than earlier than with Stelco and it is primarily non-automotive e-book of enterprise within the combine, leading to a smaller proportion of mounted value contracts for our complete Cleveland-Cliffs enterprise as a complete. And let’s not neglect about security. We had an impressive security document in 2024 and that’s the direct results of our nice relationship with our workforce. We take security significantly and the unions do too.

We reported a full 12 months 2024 complete reportable incident fee or variety of accidents per 200,000 hours labored up 0.9. And in contrast to another corporations on this business, we depend everybody inside our fence line workers, contractors, everybody. Lastly, earlier than turning it over to Celso to undergo our monetary outcomes, I’ll rapidly tackle a subject I am certain a lot of you wish to hear about. Given ongoing litigation, we won’t be taking questions relating to U.S.

Metal or Nippon Metal in the present day. However our place is well-known and our conviction has by no means modified. We now have been steadfast in our opinion that U.S. Metal’s introduced sale to Nippon Metal would by no means shut.

I stated that in December 2023, then in 2024, and I am repeating that in 2025. Simply return to our convention name transcripts and public statements, and you will see that we’ve got been appropriately predicting this consequence for over a 12 months. The truth is that the deal has been blocked by america of America on severe nationwide safety issues that can’t be mitigated. The CFIUS committee rightfully acknowledged this and particularly famous that permitting Nippon Metal, an organization absolutely financed by the Japanese banking system and their near-zero rates of interest, to turn into a significant home participant within the U.S.

would negatively impression the way forward for the complete American metal business and that will have an effect on a number of states of the union within the Midwest and past. President Trump has stated quite a lot of instances that Nippon Metal is an unacceptable purchaser for a majority stake in U.S. metal. That stated, no scenario is so unhealthy that it can not turn into so much worse.

For Nippon Metal, it is time to pack and go earlier than their epic M&A catastrophe turns into a severe diplomatic problem. As President Trump says, let’s examine what occurs. With that, I am going to flip the decision over to Celso.

Celso Goncalves — Govt Vice President, Chief Monetary Officer

Good morning, everybody. Transferring on to our outcomes for This autumn and full-year 2024. Our monetary efficiency final 12 months and significantly within the fourth quarter mirrored the troublesome market situations that Lourenco described. For the fourth quarter, we posted an $81 million adjusted EBITDA loss, which was primarily the results of weaker automotive demand and the impression of lagged pricing.

Direct shipments to automotive within the fourth quarter have been our lowest for the reason that pandemic and commodity pricing for the final six months of 2024 was the bottom six-month stretch since 2020. On condition that over 90% of our shipments are impacted by both automotive pull charges or commodity metal pricing, these multi-year lows drove a damaging impression in This autumn. Happily, each of those conditions have already begun to enhance right here into 2025 in comparison with 2024, similar to issues improved rapidly in 2021 relative to 2020 just a few years in the past. As Lourenco detailed, the automotive order e-book has been remarkably wholesome to start out 2025, due largely to market share restoration and commodity metal costs quickly on the rise.

Consequently, we view the fourth quarter of 2024 because the trough in our quarterly profitability as we gear up for a a lot improved 2025. To be clear, with the inclusion of Stelco, for each $100 enhance within the HRC value on an annual foundation, our yearly income would enhance roughly $1 billion, all issues equal. And after factoring adjustments in revenue sharing and historic scrap correlations, this $1 billion impression would largely circulation immediately right down to EBITDA. So in case you maintain all issues equal and look to the HRC curve proper now for 2025, you possibly can fairly simply calculate a vastly improved adjusted EBITDA and money circulation for 2025, particularly after including one other 2.6 million tons from our Canadian operations.

Whole shipments in This autumn have been 3.8 million tons, which was decrease than Q3 as a result of continued idling of the C6 furnace, seasonally weaker demand and solely having Stelco for 2 months of the quarter. Although the C6 furnace stays idled, our Q1 cargo degree ought to enhance again above the 4 million ton mark once more because of improved demand, higher utilizations at our U.S. mills and having Stelco for a full quarter. This autumn value realization of $976 per internet ton regarded like a pointy fall of $70 per internet ton from the earlier quarter, however this was principally pushed by the incorporation of Stelco and their cheaper price combine.

The inclusion of Stelco into our outcomes clearly helped decrease our weighted common unit prices, with a discount of roughly $15 per internet ton in comparison with the prior quarter. Although we weren’t working at full capability with the C6 furnace down, we proceed to cut back price throughout the board. At the moment final 12 months, we guided that our unit metal price could be down $30 per ton 12 months over 12 months. That is precisely what we completed, even within the face of all of the headwinds we noticed in 2024.

Now with Stelco within the combine, we count on our common price to say no one other $40 per internet ton in 2025. The fee benefit at Stelco is nicely documented and the latest weakening within the Canadian greenback has solely fortified that benefit even additional. It is not simply on the operational aspect both, taking a look at our SG&A for 2024, we have been down practically $100 million or 16% from the prior 12 months, due primarily to decrease incentive compensation. From a stability sheet perspective, we stay in a remarkably wholesome liquidity place following our newest capital elevate, the place we changed safe ABL borrowings with long-term unsecured notes.

As of in the present day, we sit right here with $3 billion in liquidity and all of our secured debt capability stays intact. Following the acquisition and the money use within the fourth quarter, our leverage sits above our 2.5 instances goal on a internet debt-to-EBITDA foundation. And as we’ve got executed traditionally, that pivots us immediately into debt discount mode. If you happen to take a look at Cliffs’ latest historical past, we’ve got a confirmed monitor document of levering as much as make strategic acquisitions and subsequently paying down debt rapidly.

AK Metal, AM USA, after which FPT, it was the identical story every time. It is going to be the identical story with Stelco. We are going to use 100% of our free money circulation going ahead towards debt discount till that concentrate on is reached. The hurdle just isn’t even fairly excessive as excessive this time both.

In comparison with the place we stood after finishing the AK and AM USA acquisitions, our leverage is definitely already in a lot better place. On high of that, on the time of these acquisitions, our internet pension and OPEB liabilities have been north of $4 billion. These liabilities have been practically eradicated, down by 90% from over $4 billion right down to solely $400 million as of the top of 2024. This autumn was a reasonably heavy interval of money use, each from the weak outcomes in addition to the buildup of stock and the discharge of payables.

This stock construct in This autumn is primarily a results of uncooked supplies, significantly iron ore pellets, a scenario that we can rectify right here in 2025. This construct units us up nicely to quickly reply to the improved demand we’re seeing so far this 12 months. We will even have a lot decrease capital expenditures in 2025 on a professional forma foundation, significantly from a sustaining standpoint as we’ve got accomplished our main reinvestment cycle. Happily, as a single mill operation, the Stelco belongings have been very nicely capitalized and we don’t have any catch-up capex necessities like we did following the AM USA acquisition, for instance.

Our complete capex is predicted to be $700 million in 2025 in comparison with $800 million in 2024 while you embody Stelco. 2024 represented the cyclical world that everyone knows as a metal firm. I consider within the midst of our weakening outcomes with our give attention to price management and our strategic M&A with Stelco, we positioned ourselves very nicely for a considerably improved 2025, particularly as the broader market improves. I am going to now flip the decision again over to Lourenco for his closing statements.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Thanks, Celso. With 2024 behind us, we’re able to reap the advantages of this new period in America. Our give attention to manufacturing inside america lastly standing as much as unfair competitors and never permitting ourselves to be taken benefit of. These efforts are already displaying up in our order e-book and our pricing.

The golden age of American manufacturing is coming and Cleveland-Cliffs, a proud American ownered and operated metal firm producing metal from Virgin Islands from Michigan and Minnesota is on the basis of this effort, able to help home manufacturing and American prosperity. With that, I am going to flip it to the operator for Q&A. Kevin?

Operator

Thanks, sir. [Operator instructions] Our first query is coming from Martin Englert from Seaport Analysis Companions. Your line is now dwell.

Martin Englert — Analyst

Whats up. Good morning, everybody.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Good morning, Martin.

Martin Englert — Analyst

I recognize the time. Subsequent week the U.S. could transfer ahead with 25% import tariffs with Canada and Mexico. This might be along with metal tariffs already pursued I consider.

Are you able to focus on how Cliffs navigates the evolving tariff setting, its implications on value and demand? And what the technique is for the not too long ago acquired Stelco asset? And is there an possibility to maneuver slabs reasonably than end metal from Stelco into the US?

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Sure. Look, Stelco is a small a part of the complete image. And the complete image will profit extraordinarily nicely from no matter state of affairs you design, Martin, so far as tariffs. Tariffs are essential.

Tariffs are on the basis of what President Trump and Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick are planning to implement on this nation. And we absolutely help that. That stated, Stelco, like we defined throughout our ready remarks, Stelco primarily e-book of enterprise is in Canada. And we consider that through the use of our belongings supply of the border to execute on orders which are coming from American purchasers will largely mitigate the damaging impression of any tariffs on Stelco.

So lengthy story quick, we consider that any is small damaging impression on Stelco, if any, which I nonetheless do not consider that they are going to be — that would be the case might be largely offset and surpassed by the advantages to the remainder of the footprint which are so much larger than Stelco individually. One other level that I want to yet one more time name consideration to your consideration and the eye of our buyers, the very best 12 months for Stelco was 2018. And that was simply after when President Trump throughout his first mandate carried out tariffs. So we absolutely count on that would be the case once more.

Martin Englert — Analyst

That is going again a methods, however serious about simply the mechanics of reporting with tariffs in place in Stelco and adjusted EBITDA, would you intend to report tariffs included or excluded from adjusted EBITDA?

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

We will all the time report our outcomes as they’re. And we don’t even know find out how to do what we’ve got simply urged. It was not even a part of our line of thought.

Martin Englert — Analyst

OK. Sure, simply double checking. I recognize that. If I might yet one more on mounted contracts.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Go forward.

Martin Englert — Analyst

On mounted contracts for flat-rolled merchandise, how did pricing change for the January resets? After which simply up to date sensitivity for steelmaking ASPs making an allowance for these contract resets, the inclusion of Stelco relative to adjustments in U.S. spot market costs?

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Sure. Stelco doesn’t take part on that as a result of the e-book of enterprise is mainly spot. I’d say spot. We haven’t any contracts to talk of in Stelco.

It is all spot and that is an incredible factor within the present pricing setting. So for the remainder of Cliffs, the mounted contracts are going — negotiations are going extraordinarily nicely, extraordinarily nicely amongst different issues as a result of we had a really uncommon 2024 through which two home opponents determined to actually dump from the within. And in some conditions, we elected to not play that sport. And considered one of our then huge purchasers grew to become extraordinarily weak and they’re now not a significant participant, not solely due to us, however due to different issues.

So however we helped them turn into weaker. Even this consumer is coming again. All people else is coming again and coming again rapidly. So the state of affairs is the precisely reverse of what we had in 2024 once they had a low value excessive fueling all the pieces.

At this level, actuality is sinking in and nothing like having a authorities that’s dedicated to carry manufacturing again throughout the borders of america. So all people is coming to get the home provider. The home provider is Cleveland-Cliffs.

Martin Englert — Analyst

I recognize all the colour and good luck within the 1Q right here. Thanks.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Thanks, sir.

Operator

Thanks. Subsequent query is coming from Nick Giles from B. Riley. Your line is now dwell.

Nick Giles — B. Riley Monetary — Analyst

Thanks, operator, and good morning, everybody. Lourenco and Celso, I recognize all of the background in your earlier debt paydown. I used to be curious that if we have been to see the fairness stay underneath strain, in case you may think about pausing paydown for any share repurchases? After which my second query was, do you’ve a goal degree of internet debt in thoughts? Thanks very a lot.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Nicely, to start with, Nick, congrats in your promotion. And I’ll miss Lucas Pipes. However I do know that Lucas went to a spot that I am certain that he’ll turn into an enormous shareholder of Cleveland-Cliffs. In order that’s an incredible factor for Lucas, and I am certain that might be an incredible factor for B.

Riley. And I hope will probably be nice for you as nicely, Nick. So far as that, let me begin from the targets. I feel, Celso talked about that we’re sustaining our goal of two level instances EBITDA as our goal.

And you are going to say, oh, however we’re a lot larger proper now. Nicely, we’re a lot decrease than once we — after we acquired ArcelorMittal USA for instance. So we all know find out how to do these items. M&A just isn’t for vacationers.

M&A is for those that perceive find out how to do M&A, timing, find out how to execute and through the backlash of getting a few quarters just like the This autumn that you simply noticed. We all know what we’re doing. We ready in This autumn to an incredible 2025. So we expect a totally completely different 12 months and we’re enduring the unhealthy outcomes and are going to emerge from that time.

So far as shopping for again inventory, the reply is a powerful no. At this level, there may be completely no different factor that we’ll do besides paying down debt. Paying down debt is the factor that we’ll proceed to construct the worth of our fairness. So the reply isn’t any.

Nick Giles — B. Riley Monetary — Analyst

Lourenco, that is good to listen to and I actually recognize the form of feedback. I am certain Lucas would say the identical. My subsequent query was, curious how we must always take into consideration quantity cadence over the course of the 12 months? And the way a lot of your price steerage could possibly be predicated on higher mounted price absorption versus decrease uncooked materials prices?

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Sure, I am going to let Celso reply that one, Nick, please.

Celso Goncalves — Govt Vice President, Chief Monetary Officer

Sure. Hey, Nick. Simply to echo Lourenco’s feedback, congrats once more. In order we glance towards the remainder of 2025 and I wish to really tackle a query that Martin had requested beforehand because it pertains to ASPs that I do not assume we absolutely answered.

Following the acquisition of Stelco, we’ll have a smaller proportion of our quantity underneath mounted costs. In order we glance towards the remainder of this 12 months, solely about 30% to 35% of our volumes are underneath mounted pricing. After which you’ve about 20% on a CRU month lag, name it 10% on a two-month lag for slabs and 5% on 1 / 4 lag. So I simply wished to be sure that was addressed as nicely.

After which from a price standpoint, we guided to a $40 a ton discount for the complete 12 months. And you are going to see that materialize extra within the again half of the 12 months than right here in Q1, however it may be a consequence of the favorable price combine from the Stelco acquisition, optimization of the built-in footprint and clearing of form of larger price stock. However that is what we’re guiding for the complete 12 months.

Nick Giles — B. Riley Monetary — Analyst

Thanks a lot, Celso. And simply to make clear, in order that these price reductions wouldn’t embody potential of bringing C6 again on-line?

Celso Goncalves — Govt Vice President, Chief Monetary Officer

Appropriate. Sure, we’re not bringing C6 again at this level.

Nick Giles — B. Riley Monetary — Analyst

Bought it. Nicely, Lourenco, Celso, thanks a lot for all of your feedback and continued better of luck.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Thanks.

Operator

Thanks. Subsequent query is coming from Philip Gibbs from KeyBanc Capital Markets. Your line is now dwell.

Philip Gibbs — Analyst

Hey. Good morning.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Good morning, Phil.

Philip Gibbs — Analyst

I wish to discuss a bit bit in regards to the capital expenditures this 12 months and into the longer term. I do know you have bought some fairly materials tasks that you simply’re engaged on over the following few years. So I do not wish to lose sight of the long run evolution with Middletown and Butler. Perhaps give us some ideas on the place these tasks stand and timelines and the way you are serious about these proper now?

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Positive. Our capex for this 12 months could be very clear, $500 million for the legacy Cleveland-Cliffs footprint, $100 million for the Stelco footprint, that is in all probability within the excessive aspect, despite the fact that that is our quantity for the reason that second that we dedicated of the acquisition of Stelco. However this $100 million could possibly be some financial savings right here. I am undecided if we’ll — will probably be essential to spend the complete $100 million on this 12 months, however that is the quantity we’ve got in our books proper now.

And one other $100 million for the three tasks, Middletown, Butler and Weirton. And that is just about what we’re planning to spend this 12 months. So far as subsequent 12 months, it would all rely upon how issues will go, significantly within the Middletown one. I consider that Weirton goes quick and goes in the proper course.

Butler, the identical factor, the modernization of the furnaces at Butler. And you understand how vital grain-oriented electrical steels is for us. So we are going to proceed to spend that cash. Within the Middletown undertaking, it is all about what is going on to occur subsequent with the efforts to provide hydrogen within the space.

That undertaking can turn into extra towards pure gasoline, which for me is extra comfy as a result of it is one thing that we dominate, significantly a direct discount plant function underneath pure — utilizing pure gasoline as reductant. That is precisely what we’re have in Toledo. In order that’s the one caveat that I’ve for that particular undertaking. However it’s so far-off.

We now have a lot time to proceed to debate with the brand new Division of Vitality and we are going to go from there. So we’re in good condition in all three.

Philip Gibbs — Analyst

After which on the Weirton undertaking for electrical steels and associated gear, I am unable to keep in mind, do you’ve a associate there now?

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

We do.

Philip Gibbs — Analyst

I assumed that there was some dialogue of that. OK. You do?

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Sure, we do. We do. We do and we purchase gear. So on the proper time, we are going to evaluate all of the names and all the pieces.

However the level is, it is on time and the orders are in place and we’re shifting very, very expeditiously to start out producing transformers in Weirton and one 12 months for now.

Philip Gibbs — Analyst

Thanks. After which my final query is simply on some — perhaps some clarification simply to start out the 12 months. It feels like you’ll have a bit bit higher quantity than the fourth quarter, significantly with the added month of Stelco. However then it feels like within the legacy enterprise, you are additionally swapping an honest quantity of tons, name it service middle for extra direct automotive as you have regained some share after which have some new applications kicking in and a few first rate demand.

So placing that every one collectively, do you even have, respecting that there is additionally lags, however do you’ve larger pricing combine within the first quarter than you do within the fourth? Thanks.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Sure, we could have a better value combine since you talked about the principle cause, we’ll have extra automotive within the combine. However make no mistake, total, while you on the finish of 2025, Phil, while you evaluate 2025 with, for instance, 2021, you’re going to see a greater 2025 compared to 2021 as a result of total we’re going to have the ability to profit from value enhance extra instantaneously than we had in that 12 months. As a result of on that 12 months, we’re overloaded with automotive. At the moment, we’re not.

So the enterprise that is coming again to us is primarily enterprise that can profit from the upper costs instantly as a substitute of getting a lag that’s tied to a contract with automotive. Truly, a few opponents of Cleveland-Cliffs could have this drawback and they’re going to have this drawback with a value that is actually low that the value that they dedicated final 12 months that I didn’t settle for. So 2024 was theirs. 2025 might be ours.

Philip Gibbs — Analyst

Sure. Thanks a lot.

Celso Goncalves — Govt Vice President, Chief Monetary Officer

So perhaps so as to add some numbers to that. No, simply to place some numbers round it, for Q1 ASPs, we’re anticipating to be up a minimum of $10 a ton from This autumn. Clearly, the month-to-month lag contracts might be barely higher. The quarterly lag contracts are going to be challenged nonetheless, however you are going to see these elevated auto shipments from This autumn to Q1 will even profit pricing.

Philip Gibbs — Analyst

Thanks a lot. Respect the clarification.

Operator

Thanks. Subsequent query is coming from Chris LaFemina from Jefferies. Your line is now dwell.

Chris LaFemina — Analyst

Thanks, operator. Hey, guys. Thanks for taking my query. Hey, Lourenco, simply first, rapidly.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Hello, Chris.

Chris LaFemina — Analyst

How are you doing? Simply rapidly on the metal markets. I imply, clearly, costs have actually begun to maneuver larger and also you talked about your order books getting higher. And we’ve got the upcoming impression of tariffs, which might clearly be good for the medium to long run for you. However I am simply questioning about form of the cadence of demand.

And is it potential that there is been some demand that is being pulled ahead forward of tariffs? And perhaps after tariffs kick-in, we get a interval the place we’ve got type of consolidation earlier than the costs begin to transfer larger or do you assume that is extra a mirrored image of demand actually recovering after a really weak 2024? That is my first query.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Sure, I feel that may be a mixture of all the pieces, however demand is coming again — as 2025 progresses, Chris, you’re going to see an increasing number of home consumption for the straightforward undeniable fact that they don’t seem to be going to have the ability to import anymore. Whenever you put tariffs on metal on each single nation and when you do not settle for exceptions, you do not create mechanisms for folks to begin to sport the system by submitting exceptions. And extra importantly, once we shut down the door in Mexico that brings metal via Mexico into america and destroys {the marketplace} then we’ve got an incredible mixture to enhance and to extend demand. After all, within the short-term, there might be form of a rearrangement of the provision chains.

However look no one can say that it is environment friendly to love the CEO of OneSteel firm stated some components transfer throughout the border between america and Mexico seven instances. After which they recall that effectivity. My goodness, that is silly with all due respect. So let’s produce all the pieces right here in america and get issues again the place they belong.

And remember, for a rustic like Mexico, tariffs might be stacked. So it is 25% plus 25% makes up 50%. So for those that relied in Mexico, time to get one other factor to do.

Chris LaFemina — Analyst

Nice. Thanks for that. After which, Celso, simply on the working capital construct within the first quarter, would you count on that to start to reverse within the second quarter? So ought to we begin to have money inflows via the remainder of the 12 months from working capital? And I am questioning if we would see over the course of the 12 months, the online money outflow from working capital within the first quarter be greater than offset over the course of the 12 months? So in different phrases, you get doubtlessly for the complete 12 months, you get a profit from working capital reasonably than the draw they’d within the first quarter?

Celso Goncalves — Govt Vice President, Chief Monetary Officer

Sure, that is proper. You nailed it. The working capital construct in This autumn was to gear up for a a lot improved 2025. It was principally all stock pushed, significantly in uncooked supplies, pellets and coke.

So we’ll be capable to work via all this in 2025.

Chris LaFemina — Analyst

OK. Nice. Thanks, guys and good luck.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Chris, only one thing more on capital — on working capital. I might have shut down Minnesota a minimum of one mine or mine and a half and produce fewer pallets in This autumn and present a greater quantity and no one might be saying, oh, there is a money burn and this and that. I did not try this. I produced the pellets.

Are you aware why? As a result of I had full confidence that President Trump would hold the promise that he made. Promise made, promise stored. And tariffs are coming, demand is coming and I’ve the pellets. Keep in mind, there’s a winter between the pellets and the consuming mills.

I’ve the pellets able to go. So we’re prepared for these tariffs to be carried out. We’re able to maintain the market. We’re not going to justify, we do not have feedstock, we do not have scrap, we do not have pellets, we do not have folks.

We now have all the pieces. We produced much less tons, however the workers are there and we’re able to go. And that is what you do if you find yourself managing for the longer term and managing for the close to future. So that is the working capital factor that I would really like you to grasp.

And please make your mannequin display that as a result of that is going to occur all through 2025.

Chris LaFemina — Analyst

That is smart. Thanks, Lourenco. Good luck.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Thanks.

Operator

Thanks. Subsequent query in the present day is coming from the road of Carlos De Alba from Morgan Stanley. Your line is now dwell.

Carlos De Alba — Analyst

Sure. Thanks very a lot. Good morning. Celso, simply to make clear on the working capital, do you count on working capital to generate money in Q1 or to devour money in Q1? So I assumed that after the rise within the fourth quarter, you would cut back working capital within the first quarter.

Celso Goncalves — Govt Vice President, Chief Monetary Officer

Sure, will probably be comparatively impartial in Q1, Carlos. However you will begin to see the profit in subsequent quarters.

Carlos De Alba — Analyst

Proper. OK, nice. And a few extra questions. One is, on the auto value for 2025, any extra coloration which you can provide? Do you count on costs to be flattish, to maneuver larger, transfer down, clearly recognizing that now the mounted costs total characterize a much less proportion of your total volumes?

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Sure, the complete image of automotive will characterize much less of a proportion of the general quantity and that is a internet optimistic for us. However our costs needed to go barely down in some renegotiations, however not even near what my competitors was locking in for 2024. So after I say it is barely down, say it is barely down, however not the absurd that the home dumping that I needed to compete in opposition to in 2024.

Carlos De Alba — Analyst

All proper. Thanks. And so wanting on the stability sheet and your working capital and money circulation technology, clearly the precedence is to carry down debt. Any and look I perceive that you’re very optimistic on 2025, issues are bettering, costs are up, your volumes are going to be larger, your prices are coming down.

And is the elephant on the room, I’ll simply tackle it. Is there a risk of an fairness issuance or at this cut-off date, you’re feeling that’s not wanted?

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

I normally problem fairness when this — the fairness — the value per share is excessive. When the value per share is low, I problem unsecured debt as a result of I do know that I can do it and I can do it in a few hours. Celso did that problem with out even my assist. And we’ve got a following and we recognize our bondholders.

They perceive our firm extraordinarily nicely they usually know what we’re doing. So the reply isn’t any. We’re not going to problem fairness. We’re not going to do something.

We did — we issued unsecured debt to enlarge our liquidity. And in case you take a look at the quantity, you will see that what we did on this final issuance was simply offsetting the usage of money that we put to make use of to amass Stelco. So it is simply a part of the M&A method and all the pieces goes accordingly to plan, together with the truth that we knew that in 2025, we would have a brand new starting for manufacturing in america and we absolutely help that and we are going to proceed to work to make this factor occur for the nation and for Cliffs and for our shareholders.

Celso Goncalves — Govt Vice President, Chief Monetary Officer

Sure, Carlos, there isn’t any want to boost fairness or to problem fairness at the moment. We have been very proactive on the stability sheet on the capital construction. We did these unsecured offers to boost liquidity. Now we’ve got all of the liquidity that we want.

We now have secured capability as nicely. And much more importantly, we’ve got a capital construction that is designed — that is pre-designed for debt discount. We now have the ABL, that is form of the No. 1 goal of free money circulation going ahead.

However we even have — our bonds are nicely staggered in a means that they turn into callable with no penalty beginning this 12 months. So even after we have paid down the complete ABL, we’ve got these completely different tranches of bonds that we will begin to assault. So it is debt discount from free money circulation technology with no fairness elevate.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

And once more, in case you take a look at the stack, you are going to see that the capital construction was put in place that means by design. So we knew that we’d begin having tranches of our bonds able to be paid down or paid off with money circulation technology beginning 2025.

Carlos De Alba — Analyst

OK. And understanding that you could be not reply this query based mostly on what you stated earlier within the name and I respect that. I’ll respect that clearly. And the stability sheet, is there a limitation to pursue one other acquisition as you’ve highlighted previously?

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Let’s have a look at what occurs. There is a man that claims that so much. When he says that, those which are within the receiving finish, they normally they know that they are in a foul spot. Let’s have a look at what occurs.

Celso Goncalves — Govt Vice President, Chief Monetary Officer

However to reply your query, Carlos, the stability sheet just isn’t a constraint. We have confirmed that we will elevate capital rapidly when wanted. So the stability sheet just isn’t the constraint.

Carlos De Alba — Analyst

All proper. Wonderful. Nicely, thanks very a lot.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Thanks.

Operator

Thanks. Subsequent query is coming from Lawson Winder from Financial institution of America. Your line is now dwell.

Lawson Winder — Analyst

Thanks, operator, and good morning, Lourenco and Celso. Good to listen to from you each. Celso, you talked about that bringing the Cleveland Works No. 6 again on-line just isn’t one thing that you simply’re contemplating in the mean time.

Might you perhaps communicate to the situations for a possible restart? And the way you consider doubtlessly doing that?

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

It is Lourenco right here Lawson. No, we’re not going to speak about that. There is not any topic to debate on C6 proper now. It is idle, indefinite idle and it’ll stay particular idle till we are going to resolve in any other case.

Lawson Winder — Analyst

OK, excellent. That is very useful. With the synergy, you famous, the Stelco synergies that as you famous $120 million to be achieved by year-end ’25 and also you’re on monitor to take action. You talked about potential upside to that.

Is there a time at which we might get a way of what a few of that upside may be? And will a few of that doubtlessly be realized even this 12 months earlier than year-end?

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Celso, take that.

Celso Goncalves — Govt Vice President, Chief Monetary Officer

Sure. I imply because it pertains to the Stelco synergies, Lawson, we really feel extraordinarily assured in having the ability to overachieve that $120 million that we outlined. I feel we have given the breakdown of that. However in case you simply take a look at what we have executed with our different acquisitions, we’ve got a monitor document of overachieving these synergies.

A big portion of that $120 million has already been set in movement by the highest administration departures, form of duplicative board bills, audit bills and issues like that. However we proceed to establish an increasing number of distinctive methods to maximise worth from this mixture and we’ll be updating you guys over time. However for now we really feel extraordinarily assured in regards to the $120 million that we initially outlined.

Lawson Winder — Analyst

OK, implausible. And if I might ask about your Zanesville non-grain oriented line that began up mid final 12 months, is that now just about absolutely ramped up? And what are you seeing when it comes to pricing?

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

You stated non-grain oriented. Electrical steels, is that what you are asking?

Lawson Winder — Analyst

Sure, {the electrical} metal line, precisely the one which was commissioned final summer season.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Sure. Look, we made a small investments in our Zanesville plant that finishes electrical steels to extend our capability of non-oriented electrical steels of fifty,000 tons a 12 months. That extra funding paid off. We proceed to ship our non-oriented electrical steels after which we proceed to promote our non-oriented electrical steels.

Our opponents, two of our opponents making huge investments to provide much more non-oriented electrical steels as a result of they’re believers in electrical autos and the whole electrical autos will exchange all ICE autos or inside combustion engines autos in a brief time period. Good luck with that. My aim with electrical steels has all the time been to provide transformers and transformers grain-oriented electrical steels. That one, it is solely Cliffs and also you proceed to be solely Cliffs for the foreseeable future.

There’s loads of room for different suppliers to provide grain-oriented electrical steels, however it’s essential to have one factor that individuals discuss loosely about, however generally there’s nothing behind. It is known as know-how. We now have the know-how. We produce the ARMCO grain-oriented electrical steels as of in the present day, and that is the best-selling grain-oriented electrical steels in the complete world.

So we’re good at that. We now have no competitors. Competitors could be welcome. I’m pleased with competitors.

Come to compete with us. There is a market right here for grain-oriented electrical steels. We now have to provide it. Up to now it is solely Cliffs and we’re comfortable serving the market.

So comfortable that now we’ll produce transformers ourselves.

Lawson Winder — Analyst

OK. Thanks each on your feedback.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Thanks.

Operator

Thanks. Subsequent query is coming from Mike Harris from Goldman Sachs. Your line is now dwell.

Mike Harris — Goldman Sachs — Analyst

Thanks and good morning.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Good morning.

Mike Harris — Goldman Sachs — Analyst

Simply wished to have a look at — if we take a look at the anticipated price reductions in 2025 and what you have executed over the previous two years, I imply, that is about $150 per ton. I used to be simply curious has that moved you additional to the left on the associated fee curve by $150 per ton or was a few of that maybe recovering from any drift you’ll have skilled to the proper of price curve?

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Look, in fact, this quantity strikes us to the left of the associated fee curve. However the level with the associated fee curve is that we’re not an organization that is designed to function at low capability. We aren’t an organization designed to function at low-grade steels. We’re designed to provide high-end steels.

It is like in case you have a automotive and also you wish to make some extra cash and you are going to drive for Uber, it is higher to purchase a Camry as a substitute of shopping for a Ferrari. It does not work as an Uber. We’re a Ferrari. We’re good when the financial system is working, when the tremendous energy is producing issues domestically and when you do not permit others come to destroy our market by destroying our pricing.

And I do know there is a technology right here that solely is aware of mini mills. Welcome to the world of built-in metal corporations. Sure, as you’re employed for Goldman Sachs, proper?

Mike Harris — Goldman Sachs — Analyst

Sure.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

In order you might know, there may be an curiosity for a world firm to amass built-in belongings in america. Have you ever ever requested you why? Why? It is as a result of built-in metal belongings have a spot in economies which are practical and that is what we’ve got now in america. So look forward to us in 2025 and we’ll see what a vibrant financial system, manufacturing financial system fueled by home metal manufacturing can do when you’ve the proper belongings to help that sort of effort. And that is Cleveland-Cliffs and the nation I am speaking about is United States.

Mike Harris — Goldman Sachs — Analyst

OK. That is useful coloration. And simply on capability utilization, are you able to assist us with the place you might be proper now and form of the way you see that altering in 2025 given present demand visibility?

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Sure, we’re nonetheless shifting, transitioning from lackluster 2024, through which like I stated in my ready remarks, extra vehicles, imported vehicles bought in america than vehicles produced in america. In order that’s an aberration. That is legal. So we’re fixing that.

And as quickly as we’ve got an increasing number of vehicles bought in america which are produced in america, we are the ones supplying the metal for that. It is coming in 2025. Our C6 blast furnace is down and we’ll hold it down for now. So capability utilization proportion, I do not even know the way these items are calculated.

That is the image that I want to inform. We now have loads of capability to provide extra in our downstream traces and we’re very proud of the truth that we’re self-sufficient in feedstock and our provide chains are all home, managed by Cleveland-Cliffs.

Mike Harris — Goldman Sachs — Analyst

OK. Thank you numerous.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Thanks.

Operator

Thanks. Subsequent query in the present day is coming from Tristan Gresser from BNP Paribas Exane. Your line is now dwell.

Tristan Gresser — BNP Paribas Exane — Analyst

Hello. Thanks for taking my questions. I’ve two. First, are you able to focus on a bit your view on the potential dilutions of tariffs? I imply, if we take a look at 2018 and 2002, we had this sample of growth and bust tariffs in Q1 and Q2 rally after which paying for H2.

So I might prefer to have your view on why do you assume it is completely different this time? And likewise you touched on the tariffs on the downstream aspect, how a lot of that of a profit could possibly be for you? I might begin there. Thanks.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

I did not get the second half, however I am going to reply to the primary half, then you definitely repeat your second half. This time across the administration and I heard that from the a lot of the secretary, the administration just isn’t planning to toy with exceptions. The exclusions, exceptions are all the time the start of the top. So there’s loads of dedication proper now to not permit for the errors of the previous.

And the exclusions course of took an enormous enhance when President Biden took workplace. It was the time of the exclusions. He stored it, the tariffs, however they stored Q2 in place. However with so many exceptions that the holes compromised the complete factor.

I do not see that taking place at the moment round. It is a clear dedication of the Trump administration to maintain the complete factor intact and exceptions, exclusions usually are not actually underneath dialogue proper now. Are you able to please repeat your second a part of the query as a result of I actually missed that.

Tristan Gresser — BNP Paribas Exane — Analyst

Sure. No, it was on the downstream tariffs on articles of metal, so the brand new tariffs you placed on that. You talked about it in your ready remarks. How a lot of that may be a profit on your operations immediately or not directly?

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Sure. Look, let’s take into consideration vehicles. In a world of free commerce, by the way in which, free commerce is a factor that does not exist. Everyone knows that.

However in a world of free commerce, vehicles produced in China and transshipped via Mexico can hit america for $20,000. Shoppers could be comfortable to purchase. And that is legitimate for completely all the pieces. All the things imaginable.

So need not produce anything. We’ll simply be right here in america, purchase on Amazon and sue one another. So that will be our every day exercise and all working from dwelling. So this factor just isn’t going to play that means.

So downstream tariffs are vital to keep away from the leakage that will be generated by high-end merchandise like vehicles, for instance, and one thing else and one other factor and one other factor. And hastily, you do not have an financial system that may operate anymore. So we’re plugging the holes, the administration is plugging the holes, and we’re going to have a a lot completely different world than the one that you simply described with leakages and watering down the tariffs. I do not assume that that can occur.

And from my standpoint, we’re going to do no matter we will to assist the administration assist us and that is what’s taking place proper now.

Tristan Gresser — BNP Paribas Exane — Analyst

All proper. That is very clear. And lastly only a upkeep query on the money curiosity expense for the 12 months, in case you can present some steerage there. Thanks.

Celso Goncalves — Govt Vice President, Chief Monetary Officer

Sure, certain. Tristan, if you do not know find out how to calculate money curiosity bills, you simply take the coupon of the bonds and also you multiply by the quantity excellent, you get the money curiosity expense.

Tristan Gresser — BNP Paribas Exane — Analyst

All proper. Thanks. And lastly, simply on the pension advantages you booked in This autumn, are you able to present some steerage on that? And might you remind us if it is included in your adjusted EBITDA calculation? Thanks.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

$150 million is all included.

Tristan Gresser — BNP Paribas Exane — Analyst

All proper.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

$150 million in money, OK? Tristan? Did you hear?

Tristan Gresser — BNP Paribas Exane — Analyst

Sure. I bought it. Thanks.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

OK. All proper.

Operator

Thanks. We have reached the top of our question-and-answer session. I might like to show the ground again over for any additional or closing feedback.

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Thanks very a lot on your curiosity in Cleveland-Cliffs. Let’s proceed to function and maintain enterprise right here. And please watch issues evolve, issues are getting higher, it would get a lot better. And we recognize you guys following and evaluating what we’ve got instructed you in the present day on this name.

Have an incredible day and we are going to discuss quickly. Bye now.

Operator

[Operator signoff]

Length: 0 minutes

Laurenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Celso Goncalves — Govt Vice President, Chief Monetary Officer

Lourenco Goncalves — Chairman, President and Chief Govt Officer

Martin Englert — Analyst

Nick Giles — B. Riley Monetary — Analyst

Philip Gibbs — Analyst

Phil Gibbs — Analyst

Chris LaFemina — Analyst

Carlos De Alba — Analyst

Lawson Winder — Analyst

Mike Harris — Goldman Sachs — Analyst

Tristan Gresser — BNP Paribas Exane — Analyst

Extra CLF evaluation

All earnings name transcripts

This text is a transcript of this convention name produced for The Motley Idiot. Whereas we try for our Silly Greatest, there could also be errors, omissions, or inaccuracies on this transcript. As with all our articles, The Motley Idiot doesn’t assume any accountability on your use of this content material, and we strongly encourage you to do your individual analysis, together with listening to the decision your self and studying the corporate’s SEC filings. Please see our Phrases and Circumstances for extra particulars, together with our Compulsory Capitalized Disclaimers of Legal responsibility.

The Motley Idiot has no place in any of the shares talked about. The Motley Idiot has a disclosure coverage.

Cleveland-Cliffs (CLF) This autumn 2024 Earnings Name Transcript was initially printed by The Motley Idiot