Janhvi Kapoor just lately voiced her frustration over the dismissive angle some males take towards ladies by attributing their feelings or assertiveness to their menstrual cycle.
In an interview with Hauterrfly, she identified how casually phrases like “Is it that point of the month?” are used to undermine ladies’s opinions and feelings. She mentioned, “Agar primary jhagda karne ki koshish kar rahi hu ya meri level ko saamne rakhne ki koshish kar rahi hu aur aap bolte ho, ‘Is it that point of the month?’ then, like, take a hike. However agar aap sach mein humdardi dikha rahe ho, ki, ‘Do you want a minute, is it that point of the month?’ (If I’m attempting to argue or put my level throughout, and also you say, ‘Is it that point of the month?’ then, like, take a hike. However in case you are genuinely exhibiting empathy, like, ‘Do you want a minute? Is it that point of the month?’ then that’s totally different). Then yeah, as a rule, you do want a minute, as a result of the best way our hormones are off the charts, the ache we undergo, that real consideration is all the time welcome.”
She added, “However that condescending gaze and tone is… as a result of I guarantee you, males received’t have the ability to bear this ache and temper swings for even a minute. Pata nahi kaunsa nuclear struggle ho jaata agar mardon ko durations hote (Who is aware of what sort of nuclear struggle would get away if males had durations).”
Her assertion raises necessary questions on how menstruation is perceived and the way it continues to be weaponised to discredit ladies.
So, what does this reveal about societal attitudes towards menstruation?
Jai Arora, counselling psychologist and co-founder of Kirana Counselling, tells indianexpress.com, “Phrases like ‘Is it that point of the month?’ persist due to deeply ingrained gender biases and a historical past of dismissing ladies’s feelings as irrational or overly delicate. This undermines a girl’s argument, decreasing her frustration, anger, or assertiveness to mere hormonal fluctuations fairly than legitimate reasoning.”
Society has lengthy handled menstruation as a taboo, one thing shameful or embarrassing, fairly than a pure organic course of, Arora states, including that this angle “displays a broader discomfort with feminine physiology and a failure to acknowledge ladies’s emotional responses as reliable.”
When ladies specific sturdy feelings, they’re usually perceived as “overreacting” or “too emotional,” whereas comparable reactions in males is likely to be framed as ardour, decisiveness, or energy. This double normal reveals a elementary societal bias that continues to downplay ladies’s views.
What influence does this condescending angle towards menstruation have on ladies’s psychological well being and confidence?
Arora stresses, “Dismissing and invalidating a girl’s ideas as ‘you’re PMSing’ is a type of gaslighting in itself, making them begin doubting their very own feelings and reactions. Over time, this will contribute to decrease shallowness, elevated stress, and even imposter syndrome, significantly in skilled settings.”
Story continues under this advert
Within the office, he says that ladies usually really feel “pressured to downplay” menstrual discomfort for concern of being seen as weak. This stigma can discourage open discussions about period-related well being considerations, resulting in delayed medical intervention and untreated circumstances.