Balfour Senior Dwelling prides itself on offering luxurious lodging filled with “extraordinary selections” for its older residents.
“Exquisitely ready meals” are served from a seasonal menu, its web site boasts. The workers is “meticulous in regards to the particulars.”
Its Cherrywood Village facility in Louisville is on the “forefront of revolutionary reminiscence care communities,” the corporate states, offering residents dwelling with dementia a variety of actions from music to pet remedy.
The corporate, although, has fallen underneath elevated scrutiny after two staff and a contractor at Cherrywood Village have been arrested final month, accused of falsely reporting an assault between two residents that police say by no means occurred. That got here a yr after a 97-year-old resident of a second Balfour facility in Louisville froze to demise after being locked out of the constructing. One worker, now going through expenses, has been tied to each incidents.
However a Denver Submit evaluate of state inspection information and courtroom paperwork exhibits this isn’t the primary time a Balfour at Cherrywood Village worker has been arrested on allegations of abusing a resident. On one event, an worker mocked a resident with cognitive and reminiscence points for her speech obstacle and wetting her diaper earlier than yanking a pair of underwear over her head and pushing her onto a sofa, in line with a Louisville police report.
Workers members and out of doors caregivers at a number of Balfour amenities have been suspended or fired for allegedly stealing a resident’s bank card, bodily and verbally abusing a resident, violating residents’ rights and failing to report misconduct by different staff, state information present.
In the meantime, the household of Mary Jo Staub, the 97-year-old who froze to demise outdoors the Lavender Farms facility final yr, alleged Balfour knew its workers slept throughout in a single day shifts, frolicked within the facility’s theater room, drank alcohol and did not verify on residents through the evening.
Balfour staff, after the girl’s demise, then “fed lies and deceptive statements to the Louisville Police Division to keep away from prison expenses,” the household alleged in a January lawsuit.
Balfour has not commented on Staub’s demise, the lawsuit or the worker arrests. Michele Sepples, Cherrywood Village’s government director, declined to handle the assorted incidents when a reporter visited the ability final week. Different Balfour representatives didn’t reply to repeated emails and cellphone calls searching for remark.
“Verbally degrading” a resident
Louisville police have responded to Balfour at Cherrywood Village at the least 10 occasions since 2020, in line with information from the Colorado Division of Public Well being and Atmosphere — which regulates nursing houses and helping dwelling amenities — and police paperwork.
Senior dwelling amenities are required to contact regulation enforcement in instances of bodily, verbal or sexual abuse and practically all of those instances ended with out prison expenses.
However on March 16, 2020, police responded to the Louisville facility on reviews of a caretaker assault.
A witness instructed officers she and one other Balfour staffer, Alex Febiri, have been helping a resident with cognitive and reminiscence points. The resident, who is just not named, had dirty her diaper and wanted to be modified, an officer wrote in an incident report.
As the 2 caretakers modified the girl, Febiri, then 64, started “verbally degrading” the resident, mocking her speech obstacle, telling her she was poor and that “he had paid for all the things that she had,” the report acknowledged.
Febiri then yanked the resident out of the lavatory, persevering with to verbally degrade her, Louisville police stated. The opposite caretaker instructed authorities that Febiri took a pair of briefs or underwear clothes and “positioned it on high of her head and held the underside collectively underneath her chin, stopping her from seeing.”
The older resident flailed her arms, making an attempt to hit him so he’d launch the clothes from her head, in line with the report. Febiri then pushed the resident in order that she fell onto a sofa, the witness instructed police.
Febiri was arrested and charged with third-degree assault of an at-risk particular person, neglect and harassment, courtroom information present. He pleaded responsible to the assault cost, receiving a deferred judgment. His file is ready to be sealed this week and the cost dismissed.
Febiri, who couldn’t be reached for this story, instructed police that he recalled comparable occasions surrounding altering the resident however denied placing clothes over her head. An legal professional who represented him through the 2020 case didn’t return cellphone calls.
Self-discipline, firings and infractions
Whereas this case represented notably egregious caregiver conduct, state information present different Balfour staff and out of doors caregivers have been disciplined or fired from its Colorado amenities.
An unnamed nurse was let associate with Febiri after an inner investigation discovered she presumably had prior information of the worker’s “tough dealing with” of residents and didn’t report it, in line with state well being division paperwork.
In September 2020, a male resident in his 70s instructed his spouse {that a} “massive man that works at evening tackled me,” information present. The person reported being grabbed and shoved into his room and instructed to remain there. He sported a bruise from the alleged incident.
The resident recognized a workers member, who was not named. Balfour requested this particular person to not return after it grew to become obvious he had restricted dementia coaching, in line with state information.
Louisville police, in an incident report, couldn’t discover proof against the law had been dedicated.
At Balfour’s Central Park facility in Denver, at the least one workers member was fired and three different staff have been suspended for numerous infractions since 2019, well being division information present.
In a single incident, in July 2021, an inner investigation discovered a workers member bodily and verbally abused a resident in his 90s. Witnesses stated the worker slapped the older man’s hand down earlier than thrusting her finger into the resident’s brow and pushing his head onto a pillow, in line with a abstract of the incident. The resident died two weeks later.
The worker was fired, and state regulators discovered the witnesses didn’t report the incidence instantly, as is required by regulation. Denver police investigated the incident for doable elder abuse, however the case was refused by the district legal professional, in line with police information.
Two different staff of the Denver senior dwelling facility have been suspended and given “remaining corrective motion notices” in January of that yr for offering care to a feminine resident in her 80s with out consent, well being division information point out. Each have been additionally discovered to be at fault for not reporting the abuse.
Well being division regulators have routinely cited Balfour’s amenities for a wide range of infractions, although many weren’t deemed extreme.
Citations embrace not conducting prison background checks for workers, failing to reply in a well timed method to resident requires assist and personnel file violations.
The Central Park facility, cited 11 occasions final yr, was dinged in a single case for failing to offer care “free from humiliation and punishment.”
One quadriplegic resident was pressured to maneuver out of the residence after submitting a grievance for not receiving well timed care, state regulators discovered.
“I used to be sitting bare in my bathe chair by the entrance door when the kitchen delivered my breakfast,” the resident instructed investigators, accusing the corporate of retaliating towards him for reporting the incidents. “That is utterly humiliating. Not solely are you taking time from me that can not be changed, however you might be totally embarrassing me.”
In one other quotation, the well being division discovered Balfour workers had not administered medicines to a number of residents for lengthy stretches.
One resident did not obtain 96 doses of Parkinson’s treatment over a four-month span, leading to a sequence of falls and accidents. One other particular person missed 55 doses of an antidepressant.
A resident freezes to demise
The state well being division’s investigation into Lavender Farms after Staub’s demise final yr prompted a extra severe quotation, figuring out the ability positioned “a direct jeopardy danger of damage or demise to all 53 present residents residing within the residence.”
Round midnight on Feb. 26, 2022, the 97-year-old Staub walked out of the constructing in the course of the evening and the doorways locked behind her. Standing in 15-degree climate — clad in a nightgown, gown, boots and gloves — Staub screamed and banged on the home windows to no avail. She froze to demise on the sidewalk.
Present and former workers instructed investigators that there had been quite a few occasions during which enterprise house owners and neighbors had known as the ability to tell them {that a} resident was strolling down the road or entered their retailer and didn’t know the way to get again.
One worker stated “there was no system in place to know for certain if residents have been inside or outdoors the residence,” in line with the state’s report. The nameless workers stated that there had been “no measures in place to forestall (Staub) from exiting the residence and subsequently dying.”
Two years earlier, workers found a feminine resident in her 80s lacking from Cherrywood Village’s secured reminiscence care unit. She had been gone for 45 minutes with out workers figuring out, state regulators stated, leaving via a gate that was discovered to have malfunctioned as a consequence of a fireplace alarm.
The resident was unhurt, however was “confused and disoriented and in danger to self,” the state well being division wrote.
Three months after Staub’s demise, a lady in her 70s left Denver’s Central Park facility for greater than two hours with out workers noticing, in line with Balfour’s inner investigation that was despatched to the state. A great Samaritan discovered her making an attempt to cross a street in her wheelchair.
Louisville police investigated Staub’s demise however didn’t suggest the Boulder County district legal professional deliver prison expenses, stated Shannon Carbone, a DA spokesperson. The district legal professional reached the identical conclusion after reviewing the investigation.
“On this tragic state of affairs, there was inadequate proof as a result of… Lavender Farms is an assisted dwelling facility and never a nursing dwelling,” Carbone wrote in an e-mail. “That could be a vital distinction by way of the extent of care required and offered.”
Police confirmed that one of many caregivers checked on Staub through the nightly rounds, she stated.
“To show a case of this nature, the DA’s workplace would wish to show a gross deviation from the usual of care by the 2 caregivers,” Carbone wrote.
Staub’s household, although, says Balfour staff repeatedly lied to police and omitted key particulars through the investigation.
The 2 staffers on obligation that evening spent the majority of their shift within the Lavender Farms’ third-floor theater room, leaving the nurse’s station unattended for nearly six hours, the household’s attorneys wrote in an amended grievance filed final month.
The lawsuit additionally accuses Balfour of breaking the regulation by not reporting to the state {that a} second resident additionally wandered the halls and exited the constructing the identical evening. (She was discovered within the morning locked within the vestibule.)
The household’s attorneys name into query a number of staff’ testimony to police, together with Lavender Farms’ performing supervisor, Dainzu Mosqueda.
She allegedly instructed officers that the 2 in a single day workers members have been busy coping with the opposite resident the evening Staub died — regardless of surveillance footage displaying this resident wandering the halls alone earlier than getting trapped within the constructing’s vestibule for hours.
Mosqueda can be one of many three staff from Cherrywood Village going through expenses over falsely reporting an assault between two residents in January that police say by no means occurred.
Police took a 92-year-old man into custody on Jan. 10 after two staff — Joshua Merrill, a workers member, and Kara Roberts, a contractor — instructed them that the resident struck his spouse a number of occasions whereas visiting her residence.
However when officers reviewed surveillance two weeks later, they realized the assault by no means occurred, in line with arrest affidavits.
Mosqueda allegedly instructed police she was instructed by higher-ups at Balfour to not inform authorities in regards to the video footage, her arrest affidavit states. She was charged with one depend associated to the obligatory reporting of mistreatment of at-risk elders and is ready for arraignment in Could.
Merrill and Roberts face expenses of try and affect a public servant — a felony — in addition to caretaker neglect and two counts of false reporting.
Not one of the three have responded to requests for remark.
Fines capped at $2,000 a yr
A number of arrests at one senior dwelling facility are hardly an on a regular basis incidence, stated Erica Corson, Boulder County’s long-term care regional ombudsman.
She may solely consider three different conditions in 12 years within the county that led to arrests.
“It’s not frequent,” Corson stated.
Balfour, usually, has an incredible status, stated Cindy Cook dinner, proprietor and founding father of Growing old at 5280, a senior placement and referral company. She pointed to extreme staffing shortages which have decimated the senior care trade, notably through the COVID-19 pandemic.
“It’s a burnout enterprise,” she stated.
Regardless of a number of severe violations, Balfour assisted dwelling residences in Colorado have been fined simply six occasions over the previous 5 years, totaling $5,250, a state well being division spokesperson stated.
Lavender Farms was fined $1,500 after Staub’s demise and $500 in January. Central Park was docked $1,000 every in February and October 2022. One other Denver residence — Balfour at Riverfront Park — paid $750 in 2021. And Balfour Retirement Group in Louisville was issued a $500 tremendous final yr.
Cherrywood Village was not fined.
The Central Park residence, nevertheless, couldn’t have been fined a cent extra final yr. The state well being division solely has the authority to levy $2,000 per facility per yr.
These are paltry numbers in comparison with different states. In Florida, fines for probably the most extreme incidents at assisted dwelling amenities can’t be lower than $5,000 and may attain as much as $10,000 per violation. Oregon, in instances of substantiated abuse that ends in demise, severe damage, rape or sexual abuse, can levy as much as $15,000 per violation.
Different Colorado industries face far steeper monetary penalties for misconduct.
The Division of Insurance coverage can hit corporations with as much as $750,000 in penalties in probably the most excessive instances. The Public Utilities Fee is ready to levy as much as $11,000 per violation for some transportation and towing infractions.
Even gasoline and electrical regulators within the state — which can not impose penalties of greater than $2,000 — can assess double and triple penalties in some circumstances.
Get extra Colorado information by signing up for our every day Your Morning Dozen e-mail e-newsletter.