Vishwaskumar Ramesh, the only survivor of Thursday’s Air India flight 171 crash that killed 241 folks, defied all odds to make it out alive. Remarkably, he escaped from the entrance of the plane—an space usually thought-about much less protected than the rear within the occasion of a crash.
Kumar, who’s at present recovering from accidents in an area hospital, informed DD Information — “The aspect of the aircraft I used to be on landed on the bottom subsequent to the hostel. When the door broke, I noticed that there was area, and tried to get out. On the other aspect, there was the hostel, and I noticed nobody might go away from there. There was some area (to exit) solely the place I used to be (seated).”
11-A was the seat the place the only survivour of the Air India crash was seated. (Photograph: X/@Osint613)
Row 11 on Boeing’s 787 Dreamliner—the plane that crashed right into a hostel for medical college students in Ahmedabad—is situated simply behind an exit door on both aspect, with enterprise class seats positioned forward. Seat 11A, a window seat, is true subsequent to the exit door, with a cabin crew seat going through it immediately in entrance.
“All of it occurred earlier than my eyes. I personally can’t consider how I escaped alive. For a while, I additionally thought I’m going to die. Nonetheless, when my eyes opened, I realised I’m alive. I eliminated my seat belt and tried to go away the aircraft. In entrance of me, an air hostess and a few passengers had been all lifeless,” Kumar mentioned within the video interview.
Most secure Seat
A confluence of things would have resulted in Kumar popping out alive from the crash. Which is the most secure seat in an plane and would 11A qualify? There isn’t a clear reply. However the tail part is seen to be the most secure from a statistical viewpoint.
Kumar was seated simply forward of the wing field space, the projected a part of the wing that’s structurally stronger than the remainder of the plane. The wings are loaded with jet gasoline and certain exploded on impression. Being forward by three rows would have helped.
By sheer luck, the part of the plane the place Kumar was seated struck the bottom—not like the tail, which lodged atop the hostel—and considerably withstood the impression of the explosion. Extra importantly, an exit door instantly to his left, with open area exterior, supplied a transparent path to flee, in keeping with his testimony.
Story continues beneath this advert
Entrance — Much less Secure
Statistically, the entrance of the aircraft—the place Kumar escaped from—is taken into account much less protected than the rear. The Time journal, in a 2015 examine, analysed 35 years of crash information as much as that yr and reported that fewer individuals who had been sitting within the again died in aircraft crashes.
In keeping with the examine, seats within the again third of the plane had a 32 per cent fatality fee, in contrast with 39 per cent within the center third, and 38 per cent within the entrance third. Taking a look at row place, the examine discovered that the center seats within the rear of the plane had the perfect outcomes (28 per cent fatality fee). The worst-faring seats had been on the aisle within the center third of the plane cabin (44 per cent fatality fee).
In April 2012, a group of tv studios staged an airplane crash in Mexico, the place a Boeing 727-200 fitted with crash check dummies and different scientific devices was flown into the bottom. The check end result confirmed that passengers on the entrance of an plane can be those most in danger in a crash, whereas these seated nearer to the airplane’s wings had been reported as having suffered survivable accidents. The check dummies close to the tail part had been largely intact, so most passengers there would have seemingly walked away with out critical damage.
One other examine, carried out by American standard science journal Well-liked Mechanics in 2007, discovered that these seated behind the trailing fringe of the plane wing had a survival fee of 69 per cent. It was 56 per cent for these within the center part, and 49 per cent for the seats within the entrance of the aircraft.
Story continues beneath this advert
These statistical developments are very particular to the circumstances of the crash in query. In some crashes, akin to when the tail hits the bottom first, fatalities may very well be larger within the rear of the plane. In others, the place the entrance or the center of the plane bears the foremost brunt of the impression, these within the rear could have a greater shot at surviving the accident.
It’s value noting that the Time journal examine discovered that in a variety of crashes, survival was random — “those that perished had been scattered irregularly between survivors”.
The FAA has constantly acknowledged that there’s no one part of an airplane that is kind of protected than one other and that an important factor passengers can do for his or her security on any flight is comply with crewmember directions.