Garry Kasparov: Gukesh’s world championship title ‘not the same’ as Magnus Carlsen’s or mine | Chess News

The Indian teenager, in truth, made historical past because the youngest world champion within the sport on the age of 18 final 12 months when he took down Ding in Singapore.

Nonetheless, when requested about Gukesh changing into a world champion as an adolescent, Garry Kasparov had some pointed observations to make.

“Gukesh received honest and sq. however you’ll be able to hardly name him the strongest participant on the earth. I don’t need to sound offensive however I feel Magnus ended the period of classical world champions. Gukesh’s world championship title may be very totally different. It’s nonetheless clear that Magnus is the strongest and Gukesh is but to show his superiority over others. Even gamers of his age class. The spherical 1 recreation towards Praggnanandhaa on the Sinquefield Cup was very unimpressive. The principles are the principles and the video games are the video games,” Kasparov added.

Garry Kasparov (left) greets Gukesh (proper) earlier than {the teenager}’s match towards Magnus Carlsen earlier this 12 months on the
Superbet Fast & Blitz Poland match. (Picture Courtesy Lennart Ootes)

He then apologized for his sturdy view, however doubled down on them nonetheless.

“I’m certain there shall be extra pleasure within the Candidates and the subsequent world championship match. However I apologise. I’ve to apologise repeatedly. This isn’t precisely the title that I had or Karpov had or Fischer had or Magnus had,” Kasparov mentioned.

Kasparov’s feedback got here as Gukesh performed out a draw towards Jan-Krzysztof Duda, the Polish grandmaster who helped him turn out to be world champion. Right here’s an interactive on how the sport performed out:

Chess legend Garry Kasparov with present world champion Gukesh earlier than the beginning of the SuperUnited Fast and Blitz Croatia 2025 in Zagreb. (PHOTO: Grand Chess Tour by way of Lennart Ootes)

Why Kasparov’s feedback matter

Kasparov is among the biggest chess gamers in historical past, a person who received the celebrated world championship title six occasions. 4 of these titles got here towards Anatoly Karpov. He additionally beat Nigel Brief and five-time world champion Viswanathan Anand.

Moreover Bobby Fischer, Kasparov and Carlsen have a stake on the tag of the best chess participant in historical past. Kasparov briefly coached Carlsen in his youthful days.

Carlsen, in truth, has repeatedly mentioned that in his opinion Kasparov is the best chess participant in historical past of the game.

Susan Polgar defends Gukesh

As Kasparov’s feedback aired on the dwell broadcast of the fifth spherical of the Sinquefield Cup, chess legend Susan Polgar posted an impassioned defence of the Indian teenager on her X deal with.

“Gukesh is a deserving World Classical Champion, interval! He went by way of the FIDE Candidates as an 18-year-old, the youngest within the match, and got here out forward of huge stars like Fabiano Caruana, Hikaru Nakamura, Ian Nepomniachtchi, Alireza Firouzja, and Pragg and many others. It was not his fault that Magnus Carlsen walked away from his title. If we, as a chess group, delegitimize his title as a result of he didn’t beat Carlsen, then we have to do the identical for World Champions after Bobby Fischer since he additionally walked away from his title! We can’t have totally different requirements for gamers we like or dislike,” Polgar posted.

Full checklist of chess’ world champions

Wilhelm Steinitz (1886, 1889, 1890, 1892)

Emanuel Lasker (1894, 1896, 1907, 1908, 1910, 1910)

Jose Raul Capablanca (1921)

Alexander Alekhine (1927, 1929, 1934, 1937)

Max Euwe (1935)

Mikhail Botvinnik (1948, 1951, 1954, 1958, 1961)

Vasily Smyslov (1957)

Mikhail Tal (1960)

Tigran V. Petrosian (1963, 1966)

Boris Spassky (1969)

Bobby Fischer (1972)

Anatoly Karpov (1975, 1978, 1981, 1984)

Garry Kasparov (1985, 1986, 1987, 1990, 1993, 1995)

Vladimir Kramnik (2000, 2004, 2006)

Viswanathan Anand (2007, 2008, 2010, 2012)

Magnus Carlsen (2013, 2014, 2016, 2018, 2021)

Ding Liren (2023)

Gukesh Dommaraju (2024)

Historical past of Kasparov’s feedback on Gukesh

Kasparov’s sentiments about Gukesh’s world championship win echo feedback that Kasparov had made earlier in Could this 12 months whereas the Indian teenager was competing within the Grand Chess Tour’s occasion in Bucharest.

When Kasparov was requested to match his personal feat of changing into world champion on the age of twenty-two, which was a report until Gukesh broke it final 12 months, Kasparov mentioned: “(What Gukesh managed) is an exceptional accomplishment. However I beat the strongest participant on the earth. Gukesh is in a unique state of affairs as a result of Magnus is there. So Gukesh is the official world champion, there’s little doubt about it, however there’s any individual else who’s extensively thought of, by all metrics, as a greater participant. So he has loads of room and loads of time to enhance. That’s a problem that I’m certain he’s coping with.”

World champion Gukesh Dommaraju in the course of the recreation towards Nodirbek Abdusattorov on the Sinquefield Cup. (PHOTO: Grand Chess Tour by way of Lennart Ootes)

Kasparov had then defined how Gukesh had managed to beat Ding.

“Gukesh was, for my part, a favourite (on the world chess championship) as a result of Ding was the pale shadow of what Ding was earlier than COVID. I keep in mind Ding’s efficiency in one of many occasions in St Louis (in 2019 towards Magnus Carlsen). Completely phenomenal! Simply completely phenomenal,” Kasparov instructed the YouTube deal with of the Saint Louis Chess Membership.

Kasparov had gone on to confess: “I used to be not one who thought that Ding could be a pure challenger. Ding at his greatest towards Magnus… that will be a match! However then COVID ruined him. Ding after COVID was only a totally different participant, nonetheless very tenacious, simply tons of resilience. Stable. Some attention-grabbing concepts even in match towards Nepo (Ian Nepomniachtchi), there have been a few moments of his brilliance, however not the identical participant. Whereas Gukesh was simply rising after he received the Candidates. Every thing can occur in a world championship match as a result of it’s a protracted match. However Gukesh was all the time forward. Ding fought heroically: he practically saved the match. However I feel it’s a outcome that’s justified. Gukesh was a greater participant.”

Since changing into world champion, the Indian teenager had managed to defeat Carlsen twice: as soon as in classical format at Norway Chess and one other time in fast on the SuperUnited Fast and Blitz Croatia match.

Magnus Carlsen takes on Gukesh in a recreation on the SuperUnited Fast and Blitz chess match in Zagreb. (PHOTO: Grand Chess Tour by way of Lennart Ootes)

After the Indian teenager beat Carlsen in Croatia, Kasparov had remarked: “Gukesh is a participant that’s exhausting to beat. Gukesh has many lives (in every recreation). You need to beat him many occasions. There may be some resemblance (to computer systems). He has a resilience that jogs my memory of computer systems. He’s most likely essentially the most resilient participant. Even Magnus has different benefits. However on the subject of resilience, he’s completely superb. If you happen to take a look at the notorious recreation towards Magnus (at Norway Chess), I don’t recall Magnus ever dropping a recreation when he had a bonus of +3 or +4. Why he jogs my memory of computer systems is that with machines, you lose your focus and also you’re useless. With Gukesh you need to beat him 5 occasions,” Kasparov had mentioned.

Again then, Kasparov had some sharp remarks about Carlsen.

“Now we will query Magnus’ domination,” the previous world champion, who was on commentary for the official stream, had mentioned. “This isn’t simply his second loss to Gukesh, it’s a convincing loss. It’s not a miracle… or that Gukesh simply stored benefitting from Magnus’ horrible errors. It was a recreation that was an enormous battle. And Magnus misplaced.”