Patna: A two-judge bench of the Patna Excessive Court docket Thursday ordered a keep on the statewide caste-based survey being carried out by the Nitish Kumar-led Bihar authorities. Bihar Advocate Common P.Okay. Shahi had knowledgeable the court docket Wednesday that 80 per cent of the work was full.
In a 31-page interim order, the bench comprising Chief Justice Okay. Vinod Chandran and Justice Madhuresh Prasad maintained that it was prima facie of the opinion that the state authorities “has no energy to hold out a caste-based survey, within the method by which it’s normal now”.
It “would quantity to a census, thus impinging upon the legislative energy of the Union Parliament”, the court docket added.
The interim order was issued after the court docket heard three pleas difficult the Bihar authorities’s choice to conduct a caste-based survey. The state authorities has defended the train as being essential to the uplift of each part of society.
In its order, the bench requested why a invoice to that impact was not tabled within the Bihar meeting when legislators from each the ruling and opposition events handed a decision in favour of a caste-based survey.
The bench, whereas fixing 3 July as the subsequent date for the listening to, has directed the state authorities to make sure that the info collected to date is preserved and “not shared with anyone” till the ultimate orders are handed.
Citing a notification issued vis-a-vis the caste-based survey, the court docket famous that the state authorities “intends to share information with the leaders of various events of the state meeting, the ruling celebration and opposition celebration which can be a matter of nice concern”.
This notification, it added, raises a bigger query of the suitable to privateness, for the reason that professional forma questionnaire seeks 17 responses together with particulars about how a lot members of a household earn and whether or not they personal autos, or laptops.
Furthermore, the HC mentioned the state authorities’s choice to utilise Rs 500 crore from contingency funds to conduct the statewide caste-based survey must be “checked out” via the prism of laws on that rely, in addition to the Guidelines of Enterprise framed by the state.
The second part of the statewide caste-based survey started on 15 April 2023, throughout which the federal government aimed to doc the caste standing and socio-economic indicators of roughly 12.7 crore people.
Additionally Learn: Jungle raj vs clear politics — Anand Mohan’s launch units stage for Bihar’s 2024 battle
‘Not a political challenge’
Chief Minister Nitish Kumar instructed reporters Thursday that the caste-based survey was being carried out to achieve a greater understanding of the socio-economic circumstances of assorted sections of society.
Sustaining that the transfer was not political in nature, Janata Dal (United) spokesperson Neeraj Kumar instructed ThePrint, “The caste-based survey was carried out after unanimous resolutions have been handed in its favour (within the meeting). The difficulty shouldn’t be mentioned as a political challenge.”
Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) Rajya Sabha MP Manoj Jha, in the meantime, termed the Patna HC’s order “unlucky” and added that the caste-based survey was “geared toward attaining a social equilibrium in society”.
The Opposition BJP went on the offensive following the Patna HC’s order. “Nitish authorities is making a file of kinds of dropping instances in courts. Resolution to have a caste-based survey had approval of all events and but the Nitish authorities couldn’t current a powerful case in court docket,” mentioned former Bihar BJP chief Sanjay Jaiswal.
The caste-based survey, launched on 7 January this yr, has been central to Chief Minister Nitish Kumar’s politics for over two years now.
In August 2021, when his celebration was a part of the BJP-led NDA, Nitish had led an all-party delegation to Prime Minister Narendra Modi with a requirement for a nationwide caste-based census.
After the demand was met with a lukewarm response, the overall administration division (GAD) of the Bihar authorities issued a notification final July, expressing the federal government’s intention to hold out a caste-based survey for which it issued a listing of 240 castes.
Knowledge collected through the ongoing survey was to be collated by 16 Might and launched quickly after.
(Edited by Amrtansh Arora)
Additionally Learn: Dealing with Nitish-Tejashwi in 2024, BJP’s eyeing alliance with smaller events in Bihar ‘for caste-based votes’