The Karnataka Excessive Court docket final month struck down a rape case filed towards Raghaveshwara Bharati, pontiff of Ramachandrapura Math close to Gokarna, citing a number of procedural points with the case, together with that of cognisance.
On this case, the pontiff approached the Karnataka Excessive Court docket to quash a case registered primarily based on a criticism filed by a disciple in 2015. The pontiff’s petitioner argued that the criticism needs to be thought-about vitiated because it was registered 9 years after the alleged crime, and that different points within the case could be made clear by analyzing a petition by a co-accused, which the excessive courtroom earlier thought-about.
The opposing counsel argued that delay shouldn’t be a vitiating issue on this case because the pontiff was the primary accused. It was additional submitted that the petition needs to be independently appeared into moderately than thought-about alongside the identical strains as one other accused.
A bench of Justice M Nagaprasanna, within the order handed on March 7 and made accessible lately, noticed that as per the Supreme Court docket precedent, the delay could be a problem of vitiation, particularly contemplating the size of time concerned. It held that the Crime Investigation Division (CID) was not empowered to file the chargesheet on this case because the Code of Prison Process (CrPC) required the “officer in-charge of the police station” to file the chargesheet.
About cognisance of the offence taken by a decrease courtroom, the excessive courtroom noticed that it had been achieved with inadequate software of thoughts.
“What would unmistakably emerge is that the order of taking of cognizance and issuance of course of ought to bear software of thoughts. If the order issuing course of to the petitioner is seen, it doesn’t even bear a semblance of software of thoughts, not to mention it taking cognizance for offences …… The cognizance taken for the offences towards the petitioner is on bereft of causes,” the courtroom famous.
Having made these observations, the excessive courtroom quashed the present proceedings. Beforehand in 2021, too, it had quashed a rape case towards the pontiff, as there have been points with the submitting of the chargesheet.
© The Indian Specific Pvt Ltd