Practically every week into the NFL hiring cycle, a pattern that emerged lately has already been strengthened: Everybody needs to interview everybody. Requests have seemingly been printed up in manufacturing strains as groups appear decided to forged broad nets.
Whereas the method can transfer quick with some groups, others will slow-play it to see if they will, for instance, lure Detroit Lions offensive coordinator Ben Johnson, whose potential prolonged keep within the playoffs complicates issues for his suitors. Wait too lengthy and so they run the danger of lacking out on their second and third choices ought to they not land Johnson. Comparatively, Mike Vrabel is a real free agent who can take a job as quickly because it’s supplied.
As a approach of assessing how every emptiness is considered across the league, The Athletic polled 5 assistant coaches, together with two with head-coaching expertise, to rank them from most to least interesting. There are six present openings, and we included the Dallas Cowboys as a seventh (Mike McCarthy’s contract expires Tuesday, and whereas it’s attainable he and the Cowboys attain an settlement on a brand new deal let’s not be naïve to how rapidly issues can change this time of yr).
Observe: A primary-place vote is price seven factors, a second-place vote is price six factors, and so on.
1. Dallas Cowboys: 32 factors
There may be some apprehension concerning the Cowboys’ distinctive energy construction, as proprietor Jerry Jones doubles as the overall supervisor, however primarily based on our respondents’ votes, that hasn’t impacted the desirability of this job.
The Cowboys’ intentions with McCarthy stay unknown, though blocking him from interviewing with the Chicago Bears appears to be a sign they’d like him again. Jones praised McCarthy ceaselessly late within the season. However how badly does McCarthy need to return after enduring a tolling season underneath an expiring contract? Clearly, McCarthy would have suitors if he turned accessible.
The Cowboys’ attraction is apparent. “The roster constructed to win now,” a former head coach mentioned.
The Cowboys are up towards the wage cap and want to increase annual NFL Defensive Participant of the Yr candidate Micah Parsons. There are also risks with having a bunch of extremely paid veteran stars, as a rash of accidents can rapidly expose depth points. However the Cowboys, behind VP of participant personnel Will McClay, are likely to draft nicely and have waves of youthful gamers on the horizon.
Working underneath Jones tends to supply job safety: He’s had 5 coaches since 2000, all of whom received no less than three years. Coaches across the NFL additionally acknowledge the legacy they will construct if they create a Tremendous Bowl to Dallas. Ought to the Cowboys pivot from McCarthy, they may take management of the hiring cycle.
2. Jacksonville Jaguars: 27 factors
Candidates have monitored this opening for months. With the writing on the wall for thus lengthy that Doug Pederson would lose his job, coaches eyed Jacksonville as one of the best vacation spot compared to the three organizations that made in-season firings (New York Jets, New Orleans Saints, Chicago Bears).
Quarterback Trevor Lawrence remains to be a premium draw — for probably the most half.
“Good touchdown spot,” an government mentioned. “(Lawrence’s) contract is unquestionably not best, however you’ve one thing to work with. Whereas the QB hasn’t met expectations, there’s nonetheless upside, nevertheless it’s positively decrease than what all of us thought popping out (of the 2021 NFL Draft). This job vs. a job with no QB in place is a no brainer.”
As you’ll see all through this checklist, groups with QBs have a definite benefit over the have-nots. That’s notably true this yr because of the underwhelming QB draft class.
Nevertheless, the success of this job might be contingent on getting one of the best out of Lawrence. He was terrific whereas guiding the Jaguars to the playoffs in 2022 however was erratic in 2023 and regressed this season.
Contemplating they gave him a five-year, $275 million extension, that each one however ensures he’ll be on the books by no less than 2027, the following coach received’t survive with out turning Lawrence into the answer.
“You may have a considerably confirmed QB with expertise who has received a playoff recreation,” one other government mentioned. “However he hasn’t proven the flexibility to raise, and your (roster) construct is each outlined and prohibited by the way in which he’s compensated.”
Some eyebrows have been raised this week when the Jaguars retained basic supervisor Trent Baalke, who has now survived 4 coach firings between the San Francisco 49ers and Jaguars. Teaching candidates have questions in regards to the energy dynamics inside the group.
Proprietor Shad Khan has proven that he’s keen to spend with the latest development of a brand new observe facility and big stadium renovations on the way in which. The roster is in cheap form. And there’s nonetheless one thing to unlock with Lawrence. That’s an honest mixture for potential coaches.
3. New England Patriots: 26 factors
Proprietor Robert Kraft has at all times acknowledged the poor optics of getting a one-and-done coach, so it’s particularly necessary to get this one proper. Jerod Mayo was fired after one season, the results of a poorly deliberate succession clause in his contract that led to a coach getting promoted earlier than he was prepared for the job. Due to that, the Patriots by no means went by a correct hiring cycle final January.
Now, they higher be diligent. Vrabel, the Patriots Corridor of Famer, has been considered as the apparent selection. These near the scenario consider Josh McDaniels has a very good probability of changing into his offensive coordinator.
The Patriots have additionally gotten in on Johnson, who has been selective in previous cycles however seems extra desperate to hear now. A yr in the past, it might have been arduous to think about Johnson taking the Patriots’ name, however a younger quarterback like Drake Maye has a approach of urging folks to reply.
“New England is sneaky due to the quarterback,” a 3rd government mentioned.
The roster is in shambles. They don’t have a confirmed deal with on the payroll except they totally decide to Mike Onwenu on the fitting facet, and there are questions on the inside as nicely. And with a protection that ranked final with 28 sacks, they want a lot of assist in the trenches.
However the Patriots have Maye, the No. 4 choose within the draft and a league-high $124 million in cap area, in accordance with Over The Cap. And despite the fact that Kraft’s approval score is waning in New England, he’s largely nonetheless considered in as one of many NFL’s most secure house owners.
One query begs to be requested right here: If Vrabel and Johnson go elsewhere, do the Patriots have a Plan C?
GO DEEPER
Jones: NFL house owners present their ineptitude and impulsivity with fast coach, GM firings
4. Chicago Bears: 22 factors
The Bears received a second-place vote and two third-place votes, however in addition they had two fifth-place picks. It is determined by what coaches prioritize with this one.
The roster is in good condition, though the offensive line wants a number of work. And quarterback Caleb Williams has all of the bodily expertise on this planet, however he’s nonetheless uncooked and must mature into a frontrunner, in accordance with those that have evaluated him. Nonetheless, with the fitting construction in place, each Williams and the Bears have the potential to take off ahead of later.
There are issues with possession and the ability construction on the highest ends of the group. These uncertainties will have to be fleshed out through the interview course of.
For some time now, teaching candidates believed this could be Johnson’s touchdown spot. He’s an ideal match for what the Bears try to do, notably if they will steal him from inside the division, and it’s been mentioned in league circles Johnson would need this job. Don’t be shocked if the Bears are casting a large web simply to make sure they’re masking their bases with different candidates whereas they look ahead to Johnson to get by the postseason.
Probably the most attention-grabbing wrinkle has been Pete Carroll’s involvement. Carroll, who interviewed Thursday, actually needs this job, in accordance with a supply conversant in the scenario.
The Bears completed in the course of the pack among the many voting panel, however the feeling is that they’ll nonetheless land a high-profile candidate as a result of the roster is in good condition. Will Johnson be that candidate?
5. New Orleans Saints: 17 factors
Right here’s the place it begins to get murky, as there’s a transparent drop-off from the Patriots and Bears to the Saints and the remainder.
The reason being apparent. The final three groups don’t have a transparent plan at quarterback.
The Saints, who’re a league-worst $51 million over the cap, have a call to make with Derek Carr. Financially, it makes extra sense to maintain him for one more season as a result of they will restructure his $51 million cap hit, however that may once more contain kicking the can additional down the street. That’s been the Saints’ mannequin for years, nevertheless it turns into nebulous after they aren’t successful.
“New Orleans is a approach’s away,” the third government mentioned. “That’s a tough scenario.”
Coaches who’ve interviewed for positional roles lately have been involved in regards to the roster. A lot of their greatest gamers have been both ageing out of their primes or stacking up accidents. And with cap uncertainty, the sense is a tough reset is inevitable.
Lions defensive coordinator Aaron Glenn has been linked to the Saints due to his previous with the group, briefly as a participant after which as an assistant underneath Sean Payton.
6t. Las Vegas Raiders: 8 factors
The Raiders received two last-place votes and three sixth-place votes. And but, they’re an enormous wild card due to minority proprietor Tom Brady.
They haven’t received a playoff recreation in 22 years, and so they’ve solely been to the postseason twice. Proprietor Mark Davis simply fired coach Antonio Pierce and basic supervisor Tom Telesco after one season. His earlier head coach and GM, Josh McDaniels and Dave Ziegler, lasted 25 video games. And the coach earlier than that, Jon Gruden, resigned after an investigation revealed he despatched racist, homophobic and misogynistic emails.
Davis isn’t precisely on a heater.
“Vegas has had instability since earlier than Gruden, so it’s an extended construct,” an government mentioned.
And but?
“Brady will be the calming chief the group wants,” a coach mentioned.
What Brady lacks in possession expertise, he makes up for in connections. He’s shut pals with Vrabel, so the Raiders needs to be considered as authentic gamers for the previous Patriots linebacker.
And if Vrabel is actually set on a New England homecoming, Brady will convey unparalleled ranges of credibility into any interview room. Give Brady an opportunity to speak store with Johnson, or Tampa Bay Buccaneers offensive coordinator Liam Coen or any of the opposite higher-profile offensive minds, and this emptiness will rise in recognition.
GO DEEPER
What went flawed with the Raiders and Antonio Pierce: A foul workers, QB issues and an sad WR
The Raiders even have $107 million in cap area, which is second to the Patriots, in addition to the No. 6 choose within the draft. So whereas Brady could also be one of the best quarterback within the constructing, the Raiders no less than have the means to place a greater QB on the sector in 2025.
6t. New York Jets: 8 factors
The Jets acquired three last-place votes and a sixth-place vote as a result of the group has turn out to be a public punching bag.
“At all times in disarray,” a coach mentioned.
Proprietor Woody Johnson’s involvement has been considered as an impediment for years, with extra particulars rising seemingly each time there’s a high-profile firing. Contemplating Johnson simply worn out coach Robert Saleh and basic supervisor Joe Douglas — two well-regarded leaders amongst their friends — and the Jets haven’t accomplished themselves many favors.
In addition they must decide on quarterback Aaron Rodgers, who turned 41 final month and performed poorly for a lot of the season in his return from a torn Achilles. If Rodgers decides to maintain enjoying, the Jets should determine whether or not will probably be for them.
GO DEEPER
Aaron Rodgers’ future: Why the Jets may preserve him — and what’s subsequent if they do not
In any other case, the roster is in respectable form. They’ve received expertise on the talent positions and on protection, and the offensive line has slowly improved. There’s work to be accomplished, however Douglas left his successor in a manageable spot.
But when a corporation simply mixed two leaders who’re well-regarded by their friends with a future Corridor of Fame quarterback and sufficient expertise at different positions to steadiness all of it out, why did it come crashing down in such spectacular trend?
And might the following regime change the sample?
(Photograph illustration: Meech Robinson / The Athletic; images: istock, Aaron M. Sprecher / Getty Photos)