Mumbai: Hours after taking cost as Mumbai’s first particular commissioner of police Thursday, IPS officer Deven Bharti tweeted, “Mumbai Police is a staff. Singhams don’t exist”.
Bharti’s tweet, although seemingly with out context, was a loaded one given the political criticism surrounding his appointment.
Leaders from the Maha Vikas Aghadi (MVA) — comprising the Shiv Sena (Uddhav Balasaheb Thackeray), Nationalist Congress Social gathering (NCP) and Congress — have been slamming the Maharashtra authorities’s determination to create a particular CP put up as one that may construct an alternate energy centre inside the Mumbai Police.
They allege that it’s going to permit the Bharatiya Janata Social gathering (BJP) to wield affect over the Mumbai Police contemplating Bharti is seen as a “loyalist” of Deputy Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis.
“The appointment is solely for the BJP to have a reliable senior hand within the Mumbai Police,” a senior NCP chief, who wished to not be named, advised ThePrint Thursday. “Within the corridors of energy, it’s an open secret that Deven Bharti is near Devendra Fadnavis. Bharti didn’t even as soon as meet the state residence minister throughout our regime,” he added.
Deputy CM Fadnavis, who additionally holds the house portfolio, has defended his determination saying the particular CP put up is like “including a lacking hyperlink”.
In the meantime, some retired Mumbai Police chiefs additionally see benefit within the creation of the brand new put up saying Mumbai is an expansive metropolis the place the duties of the police typically transcend primary crime management and upkeep of legislation and order.
The row over Bharti’s appointment as particular commissioner of police is, maybe, simply one other in a string of controversies that the 1994-batch IPS officer has weathered in his 28-year-long policing profession.
ThePrint reached Bharti through calls and textual content messages, however didn’t obtain a response until the time of publication. The story will probably be up to date as soon as a response is acquired.
Additionally Learn: ‘Spirit of Mumbai’ — forward of civic polls, Eknath Shinde govt holds 1st international Marathi occasion
Plum postings below Fadnavis, ‘punishment’ below MVA
Having held essential positions — akin to joint commissioner of police (legislation and order), further commissioner of police (crime department) and chief of the Maharashtra Anti Terrorism Squad — Bharti’s expertise of serving in Mumbai is huge.
He was concerned within the investigation into the 26/11 Mumbai terror assault, but additionally courted controversy for a similar. Hasan Gafoor, the Mumbai Police chief on the time of the assault, throughout an interview to The Week journal had named 4 officers, together with Bharti, for dithering to answer the scenario regardless of being on-ground in the course of the assault.
Lots of Bharti’s plum Mumbai postings have been in the course of the time Fadnavis was CM and held the house portfolio between 2014 and 2019.
“Within the Mumbai Police, there have been two clear lobbies amongst senior IPS officers — considered one of native Maharashtrian officers and the opposite of non-Maharashtrians, or particularly north Indian officers. The NCP, which has held the house portfolio for many of the previous 20 years, and particularly its chief Sharad Pawar, was near the Maharashtrian foyer,” political commentator Hemant Desai advised ThePrint.
“Because the BJP grew in prominence in Maharashtra and got here to energy, the affect of its central management in Maharashtra additionally grew and the occasion got here to be nearer to the north Indian foyer and officers like Deven Bharti,” he added.
Bharti was appointed Joint CP (legislation and order) in April 2015 and ultimately made a file because the longest-serving officer within the put up. He was lastly transferred in 2019 after the Election Fee (EC) directed the Fadnavis-led Maharashtra authorities to take action.
The EC had requested the Maharashtra authorities to switch all officers who’ve accomplished three years of their put up after which the state requested the fee to permit Bharti to proceed until the conclusion of the Lok Sabha election that 12 months citing his “expertise and observe file”. The EC, nonetheless, rejected the request. Bharti was then appointed the joint CP in command of the financial offences wing.
The identical 12 months, the Fadnavis-led authorities appointed Bharti because the Maharashtra ATS chief. The IPS officer, nonetheless, ran out of favour after a change in regime put up November 2019.
In 2020, the Uddhav Thackeray-led MVA authorities transferred Bharti to the Maharashtra State Safety Company — seen in administrative circles as a “punishment” posting. This was additionally the time when Bharti’s title got here up in a number of controversies.
Additionally Learn: MVA grills Eknath Shinde & BJP over border row with Karnataka, CM invokes ‘Maharashtra’s delight’
‘Typical divide and rule thought of BJP’
In 2020, retired former Mumbai high cop Rakesh Maria in his autobiography alleged that Bharti was on a “first-name foundation” with tv executives Indrani and Peter Mukerjea, alleged to have killed Indrani’s daughter Sheena Bora. The case got here to gentle in 2015. Maria claimed Bharti had been conscious of Bora’s disappearance, however didn’t inform Maria about it. Bharti rejected the allegation.
Then in 2021, the Mumbai Police filed an FIR towards Bharti, who was then further director common of police, for dishonest, forgery and below penal provisions of the Indian Passport Act. Bharti was mentioned to have allegedly pressurised a police officer to not comply with up on a case of passport fraud towards a BJP chief’s spouse.
Bharti obtained a clear chit within the case in October final 12 months. Notably, the Maharashtra authorities had modified in June with the BJP coming to energy together with CM Eknath Shinde-led Balasahebanchi Shiv Sena.
“Deven Bharti has very clearly been Fadnavis’ blue-eyed boy,” mentioned a senior Congress chief, who didn’t want to be named. “Mumbai commissioner of police Vivek Phansalkar is an easy officer with good relations with everybody. However, having Deven Bharti as particular CP will assist Fadnavis drive his agenda and assist the deputy CM in any steadiness of energy with the CM.”
Priyanka Chaturvedi, Shiv Sena (UBT) chief and Rajya Sabha MP, tweeted saying twin energy constructions inside the Mumbai Police is the “typical divide and rule thought of BJP”.
“It’s a disgrace they’re enjoying out these harmful video games of favouritism with Mumbai’s legislation and order,” she wrote.
Talking to reporters in Pune Thursday, Fadnavis dismissed criticism towards the particular CP put up saying that it’s an extra director common (ADG) degree put up, whereas the Mumbai commissioner of police is a director common (DG) degree put up. Upgrading the Mumbai police commissioner’s put up to a DG degree was one other main change that Fadnavis had orchestrated when he was CM and residential minister in 2015.
He said, “Within the hierarchy, an ADG put up within the Mumbai Police was lacking. After we upgraded the Mumbai CP’s put up to DG degree Mumbai’s expanse, for some purpose we couldn’t create an ADG degree put up. So we’ve got created it now. Although the put up known as particular CP, it’s below the jurisdiction of the Mumbai CP.”
‘Chain of command not damaged’
Retired senior IPS officers and former Mumbai Police chiefs say the particular CP’s put up, reporting to the Mumbai CP, works in principle, because it has in Delhi for a couple of decade. However clashes between personalities might make it tough.
“The chain of command just isn’t damaged. The final word boss is the CP,” M.N. Singh, retired Maharashtra DGP, advised ThePrint.
“Persons are suspicious of this transfer as a result of they suppose that Deven Bharti may be very near Fadnavis so he has been introduced to chop CP to measurement. I feel that could be a very far-fetched conclusion. He could also be near Devendra Fadnavis, I don’t know, however even when it’s so, I don’t suppose there will probably be any drawback within the CP controlling the power,” he mentioned.
Talking to ThePrint, retired officer D. Sivanandan, additionally a former Maharashtra DGP, mentioned Mumbai’s police power is considered one of 50,000 to 60,000 personnel for about 20 million folks and its duties are huge — sustaining legislation and order, prevention and detection of crime, managing VIP motion, site visitors and so forth.
“The particular CP might be given separate clear lower capabilities the place he can take cost and report back to the CP. This may assist scale back the CP’s onerous duty,” Sivanandan mentioned.
“The negatives, although, are that there are two swords in a single scabbard. Whoever is extra assertive and nearer to the administration will probably be ready to usurp energy. It might both be one cohesive household, or whole chaos,” he added.
(Edited by Anumeha Saxena)
Additionally Learn: MVA protests governor’s ‘insult’ of state’s icons, BJP factors to Congress’ criticism of Savarkar