Peter Storrie can keep in mind visiting the London studio of Herzog & de Meuron, the famend Swiss architects, and being proven a placing imaginative and prescient of Portsmouth’s future.
“It was one thing else,” he tells The Athletic. “They put it up on the display screen for us and it definitely had the wow issue.”
This was 2007 and the formidable plans have been for a brand new 36,000-capacity stadium on town’s docks. Storrie, then chief government, had accepted that Portsmouth would want to depart Fratton Park, the membership’s residence since 1899, and a proposed relocation might hardly have been extra spectacular.
Positioned in between the Spinnaker Tower and the historic naval base, a £600million waterfront undertaking that would come with residences and eating places promised a transformational impression.
“This would be the most spectacular stadium, set towards the backdrop of the harbour and the English Channel befitting the membership’s historical past,“ mentioned Storrie again in 2007, when Portsmouth have been a top-half Premier League membership.
They might win the FA Cup a 12 months later when beating Cardiff Metropolis, too, however by that point plans for a brand new stadium had been all however scrapped. Opposition had come from native councillors and the British Royal Navy, who had “operational and safety considerations” after selecting to base two tremendous plane carriers close by.
Portsmouth pivoted from the dockyards to a different waterfront web site close by at Horsea Island, once more designed by Herzog & de Meuron with little expense spared. Once more it collapsed, this time towards the backdrop of the worldwide monetary disaster of 2008. As such, Fratton Park, boisterous however restricted, stays the membership’s residence.
Portsmouth’s plans at Horsea Island (Herzog & de Meuron)
“The stadium on the docks was a improbable design, actually beautiful,” Storrie says. “It could’ve been good. It was there on the waterfront. It could’ve been an iconic venue. One of many nice stadiums if it had been constructed.
“Wouldn’t it ever have gotten via planning? Most likely not — however who is aware of? It was one of many nice designs that by no means occurred.”
And it’s a crowded discipline. For each spectacular stadium constructed by English golf equipment within the final 30 years, there was one other that did not get past the architects’ drawings or the fantasies of an proprietor.
Like Chelsea’s imaginative and prescient for Battersea Energy Station and the Gothic re-imagining of Stamford Bridge. Or Liverpool’s proposed transfer to a futuristic new residence in Stanley Park. Everton lived out three totally different initiatives at Kings Dock, Kirkby and Walton Corridor Park earlier than lastly planting a spade within the floor at Bramley-Moore Dock, web site of their long-awaited new residence from the 2025-26 season.
Tottenham Hotspur had their very own plans to knock down and rebuild the Olympic Stadium earlier than West Ham United grew to become tenants in 2016, whereas as soon as upon a time Birmingham Metropolis had plans for a 55,000-seater stadium that will kind a part of the Birmingham Sports activities Village. Karren Brady, Birmingham’s managing director again in 2006, known as it “a once-in-a-lifetime regeneration undertaking.” Or, because it turned out, not-in-this-lifetime.
That’s typical of the well-versed massive promote, particularly when supporters are being requested to depart a historic residence. Venture what the long run would possibly seem like in all its animated glory and hope it marks step one on the journey.
Actions don’t all the time accompany the phrases. Whether or not via funding issues or supporter opposition, typically each, English soccer has an extended record of initiatives which have gone to the good drafting board within the sky.
Leeds United have been driving the crest of a wave again within the spring of 2001. A run to the Champions League semi-finals, the place they have been crushed 3-0 by Valencia, had emboldened the assumption that Leeds might set up themselves amongst English soccer’s elite and a part of the grand plan was a transfer away from Elland Highway.
A wasteland web site was picked close to junction 45 of the A1(M) at Skelton and a brand new £40million, 50,000-capacity floor was proposed. Elland Highway, in the meantime, could be bought to the native council for an estimated £20million to assist fund it.
Peter Ridsdale, Leeds’ chairman, had a blunt message as they tried to maintain tempo with these on the high of the Premier League. “Doing nothing is just not an possibility,” he warned in a letter to followers.
All supporters have been requested if they’d again a renovation of Elland Highway or a transfer to a brand new stadium throughout a session course of. “On the one hand there’s the historical past and the reminiscences that all of us share, and however is the necessity to make sure that we provide future generations a world-class staff and a world-class stadium,” mentioned Ridsdale.
Three months later it was introduced that 87.6 per cent of the votes solid had been in favour of leaving Elland Highway. “An amazing endorsement,” concluded Ridsdale, who outlined plans to search out sponsorship for the membership’s new residence.
Elland Highway has been largely untouched for years (Serena Taylor/Newcastle United by way of Getty Photographs)
The push to maneuver was not as universally fashionable as Ridsdale had claimed after lower than half of poll papers have been returned however these in opposition, the traditionalists eager to remain at Elland Highway, needn’t have nervous.
Leeds’ outlay of £77million on gamers contained in the earlier three lavish years caught up with them and inside three years of Ridsdale championing a transfer, it was a Championship membership as soon as extra. Skelton was quietly brushed beneath the carpet and 20 years later, with no significant restoration work accomplished, Elland Highway and its limitations stay a headache for others to inherit.
Funding — or an absence of it — sometimes turns into the insurmountable impediment in these grand stadium designs.
Establishing a brand new residence from scratch or rebuilding an present floor is the largest potential expenditure any membership can face and, as such, is reliant on big borrowings. The most important and greatest at the moment are £1billion initiatives.
Liverpool didn’t have to search out that a lot again in 2007 however even the touted £400million wanted to construct a 60,000-seater stadium in Stanley Park proved past former house owners Tom Hicks and George Gillett.
Leaving Anfield behind had been a key thread to the guarantees of the U.S. businessmen, with Gillett pledging at his opening press convention that “the shovel must be within the floor within the subsequent 60 days.”
The earlier 5 years, earlier than the arrival of Hicks and Gillett, had seen a variety of plans put ahead, with define planning permission permitted for a Stanley Park stadium way back to 2003.
Unique plans have been redesigned by Hicks and Gillett and revised once more after a goal to start work in the summertime of 2007 was missed, earlier than any tangible hope of a brand new stadium started to recede in 2008.
Like Portsmouth, the credit score crunch and house owners with restricted assets introduced the undertaking to a standstill.
“Our dedication to constructing a brand new world-class Liverpool Soccer Membership stadium is undiminished,” mentioned Liverpool in a press release. “Like many different main improvement initiatives within the UK and abroad we’re affected by world market situations. We’ll use this era productively and revisit the plans for the stadium to extend its capability to 73,000 seats.”
The imaginative and prescient did not materialise, although. 12 months after 12 months there was no significant progress till Hicks and Gillett have been changed by Fenway Sports activities Group, who confirmed their intention to as an alternative redevelop Anfield in 2012.
“It might have been sensible however we’ve got most likely set ourselves again a number of years,” former chief government Ian Ayre mentioned in 2011. Liverpool will lastly get the 60,000-capacity stadium they’ve spent 20 years ready for when the brand new Anfield Highway Stand is absolutely opened by the top of January.
These years of uncertainty firstly of this century would usually see a contentious plan proposed. With Everton accepting the necessity to depart Goodison Park for 20 years or extra, a floor share between the 2 Merseyside golf equipment was touted on a couple of event.
As a lot as £30million was promised from public funds in 2003 for a brand new super-stadium within the metropolis. The North West Improvement Company proposed that Liverpool and Everton ought to share in a bid to regenerate the broader Anfield space and 6 years later, as England gathered collectively its push to host the 2018 World Cup. Conferences have been even held with the then sports activities minister Richard Caborn.
Goodison and Anfield is separated by Stanley Park – plans to construct one stadium to accommodate them each didn’t go down nicely (Simon Stacpoole/Offside/Offside by way of Getty Photographs)
The plans, although, have been constantly met with opposition from the 2 rivals, each within the boardroom and amongst fan teams. Everton described it as “utter nonsense” the golf equipment ought to groundshare in 2009.
That was as a result of that they had different concepts. Huge ones. Unperturbed by the failed try and construct a brand new 50,000-seater stadium on the King’s Dock, now web site of the Liverpool Echo Enviornment, by 2007 they have been pushing forward with a transfer to a web site in Kirkby, eight miles out of town centre on Liverpool’s northern edge.
It could kind a part of an infinite retail park headed up by Tesco and the capability will increase have been forecast to generate £6million extra per season. Promoting the naming rights for the stadium would earn the identical quantity once more.
Not that it ever went to plan. An opposition group, the Preserve Everton In Our Metropolis Marketing campaign, was shaped, whereas Liverpool Metropolis Council, who felt Everton mustn’t depart their boundaries, have been strongly towards the transfer. Chief Warren Bradley known as the proposed stadium in Kirkby “a cow shed in a small city”. They acquired their want by 2009, a interval of financial stress that harm the development trade, when the UK authorities blocked the proposed £400million joint improvement.
Good issues are coming to those that have waited, although. After all of the false dawns and stadium designs that by no means have been throughout 20 years, Everton will relocate to Bramley Moore-Dock in 18 months, a beautiful new stadium that shall be one in every of 10 hosts for Euro 2028.
If Everton will quickly be a part of Liverpool in having the larger residence they all the time wished, others usually are not so lucky. Chelsea supporters proceed to attend on proposals that will see Stamford Bridge redeveloped or an extended affiliation with their residence floor ended by a transfer. The capability of 40,000 ceased to be ample way back.
Historical past tells us that. Chelsea’s earlier proprietor, Roman Abramovich, was keen to extend matchday revenues way back to 2012 when the membership submitted a proper provide to purchase Battersea Energy Station on the south financial institution of the Thames. The location alone was valued at £500million and given the Grade II listed standing of the previous electrical energy station, plans have been unveiled that will see its 4 iconic chimneys integrated right into a design.
Chelsea wished to redevelop Battersea Energy Station (Vittorio Zunino Celotto/Getty Photographs)
Designs have been made public after Chelsea had been outbid by Malaysian property builders SP Setia and Sime Darby Property, regarded on the time as a way of making use of diplomatic strain.
“We firmly consider our proposals might tackle the distinctive challenges offered by the location,” mentioned Chelsea in a press release. “The design would combine the stadium with the facility station in a delicate, distinctive and highly effective manner, with all vital historic facets of the Energy Station to be retained.”
Not that it made a lot distinction. The spectacular restored web site is now residence to residences, retailers, bars and eating places.
Chelsea didn’t stand nonetheless and, three years after their failed try to purchase Battersea Energy Station, had revealed beautiful designs for a brand new Stamford Bridge. Like Portsmouth’s docklands plans, Herzog & de Meuron have been behind the drawings that will see Chelsea rehoused in a 60,000-capacity stadium by 2020. The placing photographs have been mentioned to be “impressed by the design of Westminster Abbey” and quoted, on the time, as costing anyplace between £500million and £1billion. Cathedrals, because it was likened to, didn’t come low-cost in a closely populated space of the capital.
There have been objections however broad help for the undertaking. Inside a 12 months, although, Abramovich had known as a halt to all of it. The crux of the issue? A visa.
This was a design for Chelsea’s new residence to be opened in 2023 (Herzog & de Meuron)
Abramovich, again in the summertime of 2018, encountered delays over a UK visa after seeing his earlier one expire and a press release launched by Chelsea mentioned it was the “present unfavourable funding local weather” that had been the set off to suspending a Stamford Bridge redevelopment that will by no means be revived. The remaining is an inglorious historical past for Abramovich, who was pressured to promote Chelsea in 2021 when sanctioned by the UK authorities following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine.
The dream of a brand new residence has not died for Chelsea as new proprietor Todd Boehly prepares to share new plans in 2024 however there shall be regrets {that a} stadium construct didn’t come sooner. Chelsea should make do with a stadium that homes 20,000 fewer supporters than the properties of London rivals, Tottenham, Arsenal and West Ham. Matchday revenues have flatlined at Stamford Bridge and, as of final season, meant Tottenham had a £37million annual benefit via the turnstiles.
One other membership with sudden regrets are Newcastle United, who’re going via their very own session course of on the place to go subsequent. St James’ Park, capped at 52,000, has been bought out each week because the takeover led by Saudi Arabia’s Public Funding Fund was accomplished in 2021.
Oh for one thing larger, just like the plans hatched in 1997. A planning software for a £90 million, 55,000-seater stadium on Citadel Leazes, half a mile from St James’ Park, was submitted. They included a retractable roof and the choice for capability to be elevated to 70,000.
A younger fan checks out the brand new stadium plans in 1997 (Tim McGuinness/Mirrorpix/Getty Photographs)
“St James’ Park merely wasn’t sufficiently big to deal with demand and the location itself had extreme limitations,” says Sir John Corridor, the previous proprietor of Newcastle. “We wanted a world-class stadium to supply us one of the best likelihood of sustained success.”
The plans, placed on public show, have been dubbed the “San Siro of the North” in a nod to the shared residence of AC Milan and Inter Milan, and included a plan to transform St James’ Park into an indoor area.
Followers backed the thought however others didn’t. A petition included 36,000 names opposed constructing on the City Moor and a public inquiry inflicting prolonged delays grew to become unavoidable as soon as English Heritage took an curiosity in Newcastle’s plans. By November 1997, the main focus had as an alternative been turned to extending the capability of St James’ Park from 36,000 to its 52,000, as it’s at the moment.
Fifteen or so miles to the south, rivals Sunderland had been via their collapsed bid by that time. That they had proposed constructing a “Wembley of the North” near the Nissan automobile manufacturing plant in 1992 and even integrated twin towers within the designs included in a postal referendum. “That was intentional on my half; I wished it to seem like Wembley,” mentioned former chairman Bob Murray.
The complicated was as a consequence of value £75million and embrace a 40,000-capacity stadium, 12,000-seater indoor area and retail park. Such was their confidence, Sunderland even submitted a bid for it to be one in every of eight venues for Euro ’96. Then bang… EU funding that they had lobbied for in Brussels had been pulled.
“Simply earlier than the Euro ’96 venues have been introduced, I acquired a telephone name, out of the blue, to tell me that Nissan had immediately turned hostile in direction of the brand new stadium,” wrote Murray in his autobiography I’d Do it All Once more. “A name was made to 10 Downing Road and every little thing modified. Abruptly it was made abundantly clear it wasn’t going to occur.”
Sunderland as an alternative went with the Stadium of Gentle as their subsequent residence after Roker Park, shifting in 1997. Others haven’t been so lucky.
Like Luton City, who hope to be seeing out their ultimate years at Kenilworth Highway. It’s virtually 30 years since former proprietor David Kohler shared his wacky plans for a 20,000 indoor area dubbed the Kohlerdome. Alas, he discovered neither the funding nor the location, which tends to be an issue.
There are numerous others, too. Bristol Rovers have spent 20 years trying to find a contemporary new residence, as have Queens Park Rangers, who’ve hoped to construct a brand new stadium at close by Wormwood Scrubs. Blackpool (Whyndyke Farm), Carlisle United (Kingmoor Park), Southend United (Fossetts Farm) and Grimsby City (Peaks Parkway) are among the many numerous different golf equipment who’ve devised formidable plans but nonetheless haven’t moved.
Identical to Portsmouth. “It was very troublesome to transform Fratton Park right into a state-of-the-art stadium and that’s one thing the membership wanted to progress,” says Storrie, the previous chief government. “We had the followers just about onside however sadly it simply didn’t occur.”
It was not the primary stadium undertaking to stay an architect’s imaginative and prescient and won’t be the final.
High picture: Portsmouth’s plans for a brand new stadium on the waterfront have been unveiled in 2007 (Herzog & de Meuron)