The Cognac area was at its autumnal finest: Indian summer season sunshine, the darkish inexperienced vine leaves contrasting with the bleached chalk soils of the pristine Grande Champagne vineyards, a bumper crop of grapes safely gathered in. And but there was an unmistakably gloomy ambiance across the place, which appeared out of kilter with a class that remained – to all appearances – on a post-pandemic tear of progress.
This was October 2023 – solely 18 months in the past, and but an age away when it comes to the well being of the Cognac class. What the Cognacais already knew, and the remainder of us have been later to search out out, was that their world was starting to show. Warehouses groaning with inventory within the US; China failing to choose up as anticipated following the easing of Covid-19 restrictions.
In 2021, on the peak of the post-pandemic surge, 223.2m bottles of Cognac have been shipped world wide. The quantity in 2022 – 212.5m bottles – was billed as a return to normality, being solely 4m bottles shy of the pre-pandemic complete of 216.5m bottles, recorded in 2019.
Then got here 2023: shipments totalling 165.3m bottles. That’s a drop of 26% versus 2021, and 24% in comparison with 2019. Hardly stunning, then, that I encountered a lot angst throughout that October go to to the area. Nonetheless, Cognac generic physique the BNIC sought to reassure, citing momentary overstocking points and predicting a return to pre-Covid cargo ranges from 2024 onwards.
As a substitute, nevertheless, 2024 noticed Cognac treading water, with shipments barely rising to 166m bottles. Worse nonetheless, worth dipped by greater than 10% to fall beneath €3bn (in 2022, it stood at €3.9bn).
That discrepancy between the amount and worth tendencies is definitely defined. Whereas shipments of youthful, usually VS Cognacs rose by 13.7% final 12 months, VSOP shipments dropped by 8.6% and XO by 26.4%. (There’s one purpose for this hunch – China – however we’ll get to that in a second.)
This miserable dynamic has performed out within the current outcomes bulletins from the Cognac trade’s greatest gamers. Moët Hennessy’s first quarter Cognac and spirits revenues down 17% to €736m, due to “comfortable demand” in China and the US: Rémy Cointreau’s 2024/25 Cognac gross sales plummeting 21.9% to €611.8m.
Rémy’s figures are significantly dispiriting for a enterprise that, even after current declines, depends on Cognac for 62% of its income pool. The grim information popping out of China was leavened considerably by a pointy restoration within the US, with the corporate tactically specializing in its entry-level VSOP product in a market that has lengthy been a driver of quantity somewhat than worth.
Rémy has endured two years of continually declining revenues, one thing which can or could not have been an element within the announcement that Eric Vallat was stepping down as CEO, with board chair Marie-Amelie de Leusse taking over the position on an interim foundation whereas a alternative is discovered.
We’re instructed that Vallat will likely be pursuing “a brand new skilled venture” from this summer season, which is sort of as imprecise as the normal tropes employed in these bulletins, reminiscent of “private causes” or “pursuing their profession elsewhere”. The shortage of succession planning means that one get together or the opposite had concluded that sufficient was sufficient.
It’s honest to say that the majority of Cognac’s current travails have been past the trade’s management. Covid-19, the substitute demand bubble that adopted it, the delayed financial penalties of the pandemic – and now tariffs and commerce wars.
However these issues are accentuated by the class’s over-reliance on two areas – NAFTA and the Far East – or somewhat two nations: the US and China. Even after the difficulties of the previous couple of years, NAFTA accounted for 43% of world Cognac shipments in 2024, with the Far East at 29% (and Europe at 19%).
The promising evolution of South Africa – now an 8m-bottle market – gives a tantalising glimpse of what may need been, had Cognac’s 4 main manufacturers labored more durable to develop new markets through the good years, as a hedge in opposition to instances like these.
Occasions within the US are deeply worrying, not simply due to the delayed risk of 20% tariffs (though a ten% tariff nonetheless applies within the meantime), but in addition due to the sheer uncertainty of coping with the financial whims of the Trump administration.
However the scenario in China is extra severe nonetheless. Following the Ministry of Commerce’s (Mofcom) provisional resolution to impose further duties of 38.1% on Cognac (and Armagnac, and different EU brandies), its anti-dumping investigation has been prolonged till a minimum of 5 July.
This information prompted a joint response from the BNIC, Armagnac physique the BNIA and FEVS (Fédération des Exportateurs de Vins et Spiritueux de France), following the go to of Jean-Noël Barrot, France’s Minister of Overseas Affairs, to China on 27-28 March.
You’ll be able to really feel the warning working by the textual content, because the our bodies cautiously welcome the extension of the probe, in addition to hints that the stockpiles of Cognac sitting in Chinese language ports may be permitted to be offered in responsibility free (the channel has been technically suspended in China because the announcement of the provisional tariffs, with a significant affect on commerce).
However then comes the kicker: “Nonetheless, in substance, these developments don’t alter the scenario for Cognac exporters, who’ve been subjected to provisional taxes in China since final October. For Cognac alone, these taxes have successfully excluded them from their second-largest market, leading to a 72% drop in shipments, significantly for the month of February alone.”
Due to the character of the Cognac trade, dominated as it’s by 4 large manufacturers – Hennessy, Martell, Rémy Martin and Courvoisier – it’s simple to easily view the results of the scenario in China (and the US) by a company prism. Natural income declines, revenue margins slashed.
What the BNIC/BNIA/FEVS joint press launch hints at, nevertheless, is the deeper affect on a complete area. Urging all events to resolve the China anti-dumping dispute, it continues: “This extra interval [until 5 July] should be used to discover a diplomatic resolution to take away our trade from this financial dispute, to which it’s totally unrelated, and which at the moment threatens to plunge it right into a devastating and historic financial and social disaster.”
Hyperbole? I’m not so certain. Past the glitzy bottles of Louis XIII and Richard Hennessy, the Cognac area is a fancy, interdependent ecosystem that encompasses model house owners, distillers, winegrowers and extra. For all the posh, it’s nonetheless an agricultural trade.
There could also be 4 dominant manufacturers in Cognac, however there are additionally 4,360 winegrowers and distillers, 130 skilled distillers, 14,500 direct jobs and 72,500 folks whose livelihoods rely on folks persevering with to knock again Sidecars and sip glasses of XO. If the present hunch isn’t arrested, and arrested quickly, there’ll be much more than firm share costs at stake.
“Woes encompass Cognac and its ongoing hunch requires pressing consideration” was initially created and printed by Simply Drinks, a GlobalData owned model.
The knowledge on this website has been included in good religion for basic informational functions solely. It’s not meant to quantity to recommendation on which it is best to rely, and we give no illustration, guarantee or assure, whether or not specific or implied as to its accuracy or completeness. You have to receive skilled or specialist recommendation earlier than taking, or refraining from, any motion on the premise of the content material on our website.
